CAPTAIN ELEANOR GRACE ALEXANDER; U.S. ARMY

DOB/DOD: September 18, 1940 (Brooklyn, NY) – November 30, 1967 (Qui Nhon); 27 years old
MARITAL STATUS: Unmarried
ENLISTMENT: April 5, 1967
MILITARY OCCUPATIONAL SPECIALTY: 3443 – Operating Room Nurse
SERVICE NUMBER: N2331728
TOUR START DATE: June 6, 1967
UNIT: 85th Evac Hospital, 55th Medical Group, 44th Medical Brigade
CASUALTY LOCATION: Binh Dinh Province, South Vietnam
THE WALL: Panel 31E, Line 8
DECORATIONS: Awarded the Bronze Star Medal with Merit.

FAMILY: Born to Francis H. Sr. (1907-1962) and Gladys F. Johnson Alexander (1908-1987). One brother, Francis H. “Frank” Jr. (1943-2021).

CIRCUMSTANCES: On November 30, 1967, a U.S. Air Force C-7B (#62-4175) from the 458th Tactical Airlift Squadron (TAS), 483rd Tactical Airlift Wing (TAW) at Cam Ranh Air Base, hit a mountain about 5 miles south of Qui Nhon after a bad weather missed approach. On the initial approach to Qui Nhon, the pilot was advised that the weather at the airfield had fallen below the safety minimum. He replied that he would proceed to Nha Trang, where the weather conditions were better. Enroute to Nha Trang, the aircraft hit a mountain at 1,850 feet. The presence of low clouds and rain had reduced visibility to about two miles. It took search and rescue teams five days to locate the crash site in the dense jungle. Twenty-six people were killed in the crash.

AIRCREW
Air Force Major Thomas D. Moore Jr; Del Rio, TX
Air Force Major William J. Clark III; La Grange, IL
Air Force SSgt Arturo Delgado-Marin; Columbus, OH
Air Force Sgt Stanley J. Yurewicz; Framingham, MA

PASSENGERS
Army Captain Eleanor G. Alexander; River Vale, NJ
Army SSG Edward O. Bilsie; Madison, WI
Army SP4 Bobby G. Brown; Springfield, IL
Air Force A1C Daryl L. Davis; Charlotte, NC
Army PFC William R. Godwin; Birmingham, AL
Army Sgt William E. Groves; Seattle, WA
Army Sgt Whyley E. Josh; Spencer, WV
Army SFC Bobby D. Likens; Cunard, WV
Army 1st Lt Norman F. Loeffler Jr; Oklahoma City, OK
Army SSG Jose Luis Miranda-Ortiz; Rio Piedras, Puerto Rico
Army SP5 Phillip A. Ogas; Lindsay, CA
Army 1st Lt Jerome E. Olmsted; Clintonville, WI
Army 1st Lt Hedwig D. Orlowski; Detroit, MI
Army SSG Clarence L. Palmer; Villard, MN
Army Corp Jack Rogers; Custer, MN
Army 1st Lt Kenneth R. Shoemaker Jr.; Owensboro, KY
Army SP4 Lawrence D. Snyder; Toledo, OH
Air Force Sgt Teddy Waxman; Annapolis, MD
Army PFC Libert J. Weldon Jr.; Rock Hill, SC
Army PFC Edward L. Williamson; Orangeburg, SC

*** and two unnamed civilian who names have never been published

[Taken from forest-lawn.com, coffeltdatabase.org, and findagrave.com]


D’Youville College of Nursing, Buffalo, New York, Class of 1961



From njvvmf.org

Eleanor Grace Alexander was born on September 18, 1940, in New York, to Mr. and Mrs. Francis H. Alexander. Her home of record is River Vale, NJ. She had one brother, Frank. She attended St. Michael’s High School in Manhattan, graduating in 1957. Eleanor later graduated from D’Youville College School of Nursing in Buffalo, NY, in 1961 with her BS. She worked at Madison Hospital for six years in upstate New York and moved to River Vale, NJ, to be closer to her family.

Eleanor joined the Army Nurse Corps in May 1967 and attained the rank of Captain. After finishing her basic training at the Brooke Army Medical Center in Houston, she was placed at the 85th Evacuation Hospital in Qui Nhon, Vietnam, in June 1967. Alexander was killed on November 30, 1967. She was with twenty-six other people in a transport plane that crashed three miles south of their station.

She is the only woman from New Jersey killed in action. The town of River Vale has dedicated a park in her honor.

Since I was a young enlisted truck driver with the 85th Evacuation Hospital during 1967-68, I had no conversational contact with Captain Eleanor Alexander, who was a nurse and officer. However, I do remember her well because of her beauty, and I noticed her because she was a subject of admiring conversation by all of my enlisted buddies.  She was a remarkable looking young woman who was always smiling and bright-eyed.  If I remember correctly, she had full, red-auburn hair that fell almost to her shoulders. Also, from memory, she was probably about 5’4” or possibly taller, slim, with an excellent figure, which naturally attracted the devoted attention of we lonely young guys.

When word came that we had lost Captain Alexander, everyone was very sad. We had lost other young men from our unit, and I have to say that we had hardened ourselves against such losses and expected them.  Captain Alexander, however, was different, and her loss was felt by everyone, and grief cast a cloud over the 85th for a day or two.  I think that after we lost her, we all realized that we had idealized and loved her a little, and that she had made our lives in Vietnam a bit more bearable.

The 85th Evacuation Hospital at Qui Nhon, where Captain Eleanor Alexander lived and worked, received seriously wounded Americans, allied, and enemy soldiers.   The doctors and nurses attempted to stabilize patients enough for transport home, or, in the case of enemy POWs, to be turned over to the South Vietnamese for internment.  This is what Captain Alexander, other nurses, doctors, and medics did.  Nurses and doctors had a separate enclosed compound made up of wood and screen-wire buildings, with rooms much like the layout of a motel.  This was located near Quonset hut hospital wards, some of which were air-conditioned. This is where patients were treated and recovered. The Quonset huts were connected by a long, tin-roof-covered cement walk that ran beside them. On the east end of this walk is where the wounded were triaged and admitted.  On the opposite end, to the right side of this walk, was a helicopter landing pad, where choppers landed day or night, depending on how heavy the fighting in the surrounding countryside was.  We could always tell how the war was going by the level of activity at the landing pad, and on rare occasions, everyone had to carry stretchers when helicopters landed one after another.  We were located about 1/4 mile from the main airstrip at Qui Nhon.  The 85th was located about 1/2 mile from the South China Sea.  There was a beach, but it was pretty dirty.  You could buy large shrimp from local fishermen and cook them yourself, which we often did.  The entire area was quite beautiful and exotic, except for the war going on, and the poverty of the people who had been displaced by the war, who arrived in Qui Nhon with no means of making a living.

The area streets and airport around the old 85th compound still exist today, and can be seen on Internet maps and photos of present-day Qui Nhon.

Researched history and events that contributed to Captain Alexander’s death: The following is according to Troung Nhu Tang, Justice Minister for the Viet Cong, and came from his book Vietcong Memoir:

In late 1967, North Vietnamese General Giap talked the Viet Cong into increasing attacks and planning a unified offensive against the Americans. In his memoirs, Trong Nhu Tang, Justice Minister for the VC, explains how half of the VC were non-communists and nationalists and were a potential threat to the future success of the North Vietnamese unification of Vietnam. General Giap convinced (and goaded) the Viet Cong that the Americans could be beaten with unified attacks.  These raids and attacks began to occur around November 1967, about the time Captain Eleanor Alexander flew to Pleiku to help with the wounded there, and they began occurring all over Vietnam.  The VC finally did attack in a large, coordinated, unified effort during the Tet Offensive of 1968, a little over a month after Eleanor Alexander was killed.  The VC lost around 100,000, and the Americans had around 20,000 killed or wounded.  This action effectively destroyed the Viet Cong as a fighting force, and the North Vietnamese Army took over the war against the Americans after this point.  This is what General Giap intended, so he would not be faced with political divisions or civil war after the Americans were driven out of Vietnam.

Written by Harold David Parks, Vietnam Veteran
Sources: Frank Alexander (brother), Harold David Parks (Vietnam Veteran), and NJVVMF.
12/17/2024


From Time Magazine on May 27, 2021

Captain Eleanor Alexander, 27, joined the Army after assurances that they would send her to Vietnam. But once there, she was restless working in the relative calm of a Qui Nhon hospital and sought a temporary transfer to Pleiku to be near the fierce fighting of the Battle of Dak To. Alexander wrote to her family that “for the past three days I’ve been running on about four hours sleep…I love it.”

Her letters, which were later excerpted for a newspaper article in her home state of New Jersey, took on a more serious tone as the days wore on. “Don’t worry if you don’t hear anything from me too often,” she wrote on Nov. 24, 1967. “It’s going to be a trying time up here.”


From The Providence Journal on November 10, 2013
By Leslie Brody

Heartbreak turns into pride during tribute to nurse killed in Vietnam

HACKENSACK, N.J. — For more than a decade, Frank Alexander ignored invitations to come to the New Jersey Vietnam Veterans’ Memorial to honor his sister, the state’s only woman to be killed in action in that brutal war.

Capt. Eleanor Grace Alexander was a nurse who died in late 1967 when her transport plane smashed into a Vietnamese mountain in the fog. She was one of 1,563 New Jersey casualties whose names are inscribed in the memorial’s circle of black granite panels.

“I really wanted to have nothing to do with it; I’d lost enough already,” her brother said. “What a waste the war was.”

His reluctance changed a year ago, however, when he learned that his sister’s sacrifice had made a deep impression on another generation. Tour guides told him that when student groups visited the memorial in Holmdel, New Jersey, girls were so taken by the young nurse’s story that they often made rubbings of her name.

“That was quite moving to me,” Alexander said. “It moved me enough to get involved.”

And so when his sister was honored by a new monument of her own in late September, Alexander was there to unveil it. At 70, he said the plaque made his family “feel proud and humbled.”

Eleanor Alexander was among eight American women — all nurses — who lost their lives in the line of duty in Vietnam. Nicknamed “Rocky,” she was flying back to her hospital base in Qui Nhon when her plane crashed on Nov. 30, 1967. She had just turned 27. A fiancé, a wedding dress, and a cedar hope chest full of Fieldcrest towels were waiting for her at home.

She was buried in River Vale, N.J., where she lived with her mother before enlisting. A park in town bears her name.

The special recognition of Alexander’s sacrifice comes as women are taking on more roles on the battlefield: The Defense Department announced this year that it was gradually lifting the military’s official ban on women in combat. In reality, women frequently found themselves in combat in Iraq and Afghanistan; at the time of the January announcement, defense officials said 152 women in uniform died there in the past decade.

More than 100 guests, including Lieutenant Governor Kim Guadagno, gathered next to the Vietnam Era Museum & Educational Center for the 15th anniversary of its opening near the memorial. A color guard’s salute started the short ceremony. John Nugent, a center trustee who served in Vietnam, said it was fitting to have the plaque for Alexander in the Women Veterans Meditation Garden.

“May we always pause to think and reflect,” he said, “before we commit the American military to wars in foreign lands.”

Some Vietnam veterans were teary. Nugent said later that some were suffering now from pain they had tried to stifle for decades.

“There’s a lot of post-traumatic stress syndrome among veterans in their 60s and 70s,” he said. “They’re retired and going back over their lives, and that’s surfacing.”

In younger days, he said, “We buried it. We sucked it up. We moved on. But it was a horrible scar.”

Eleanor Alexander was an operating room supervisor for cosmetic surgeries in Manhattan when she volunteered for service in Vietnam.

“She wanted to help,” said her brother, a retired Prudential executive. “She went in with a great deal of enthusiasm, and as her tenure progressed, she became less enchanted. She was spending more time helping the wounded enemy than the U.S. force, and that bothered her a lot.”

Five months after she arrived, she had her chance to treat more Americans when fierce fighting broke out in Pleiku, about 60 miles from her base. When another surgical nurse was summoned for an emergency team heading there couldn’t be located right away, Alexander grabbed the colleague’s gear and jacket and took her place.

“This is going to be a short note because for the first time we are really busy,” she wrote in a letter to her mother that November 13. “The troops around Pleiku are getting hit quite badly. … For the past three days, I’ve been running on about four hours’ sleep. Funny thing is, I love it.”

Two weeks later, Alexander’s plane crashed with 26 people aboard. Pat Julian Vellucci of Paramus was a staff sergeant nearby. Sent to recover the victims, the 20-year-old recited a prayer over her body.

“She was a goddess to us for volunteering for Army nursing,” Vellucci said. “She was our Florence Nightingale.”


From The VVMF “Wall of Faces”

November 6, 2024 — Eleanor worked for years as an operating room nurse at Madison Avenue Hospital in Manhattan. She was an exceptional professional, completely devoted to her task in helping surgeons accomplish their work. We were all sad when she left the hospital to offer her knowledge and skill to help injured warriors in Vietnam, though we understood she was driven by her inner needs to lend aid. That she volunteered was a testament to her bravery.
The main OR in Madison Avenue Hospital bore her name. She was a magnificent human being.

Rest in peace.
Imre Weitzner Jr., MD- Radiologist

January 21, 2014 — I served with Eleanor in Qui Nhon, Vietnam. We were not good friends, just fellow officers who would say hello and occasionally have a drink after work. She was gracious, hard-working, dedicated to her patients, and dare I say, quite pretty. When the accident happened and she and several other members of our unit were killed, the morale at the hospital was low for a long, long time. I will always remember Eleanor for her quiet professionalism. She was an excellent Army officer and nurse, and I am sure that many soldiers benefited greatly from her expert care. Rest in peace, Eleanor. Maybe we will meet again someday.

Fred McLain


Honored with a plaque in the New Jersey Vietnam Veterans’ Memorial, 1 Memorial Lane, Holmdel, New Jersey.



Buried in St Andrews Cemetery, 266 Cedar Lane in Westwood, New Jersey; Section 28, Plot 2, Grave 4. Photo from FindAGrave.com and contributor DanaC.


END


MAJOR CHARLES JOSEPH WATTERS; U.S. ARMY

DOB/DOD: January 17, 1927 (Jersey City, NJ) – November 19, 1967; 40 years old
RELIGION: Roman Catholic
MARITAL STATUS: Unmarried
COLLEGE: Graduated from Seton Hall University; ordained by the Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Newark in 1953.
SERVICE NUMBER: O-3139624
ENLISTMENT: 1962-1964, Air National Guard; 1964-1967, Chaplain Corps, Army
MILITARY OCCUPATIONAL SPECIALTY: 5310, Chaplain
TOUR START DATE: July 5, 1966
UNIT: 173rd Support Battalion, 173rd Airborne Brigade
CASUALTY LOCATION: Battle of Dak To, Hill 875, Kontum Province, Republic of Vietnam
ON THE WALL: Panel 30E, Line 36

FAMILY: Born to Edward F. (1886-1952) and Josephine Crane Watters (1888-1953). Two brothers, Kenneth J. (1921-2004) and Edward F. Jr. [Army veteran] (1925-1998). One sister, Myra [died of polio at age 6] (1916-1922).

DECORATIONS: Awarded The Medal of Honor, Bronze Star Medal for Valor, Air Medal, and Purple Heart Medal.

CIRCUMSTANCES: On November 19, 1967, during the Battle of Dak, one of the worst friendly fire incidents of the Vietnam War occurred when a Marine Corps fighter-bomber dropped two bombs into the perimeter where officers and non-commissioned officers of 2nd Battalion, 503rd Infantry had set up a command post with their radio operators. The soldiers of the 173rd Airborne Brigade were dug in on the steep southern slope of Hill 875, fighting beside napalm fires and exposed to the guns of the North Vietnamese Army shooting from tunnels nearby. Just past dusk, after making three dry runs over the battlefield, the Marine Corps A-4 attack jet descended to 1,000 feet above the jungle and released two 250-pound Mk-81 bombs fitted with Snakeye fins. Barreling in on a shallow 10-degree angle at hundreds of miles per hour, the two bombs from the A-4 hit the ground. One was a dud. The other exploded in a huge orange fireball. Instead of hitting the North Vietnamese, the bomb struck the branches of a lone tree along the Americans’ perimeter, under which the battalion had set up their command post. It was also a casualty-collection point where the most badly wounded soldiers were being treated by medics while awaiting medevac helicopters to take them off the hill. The bomb killed 21 men and wounded 10 more, including most of the remaining senior leaders and medics. A single radio operator was spared when he was protected by a pile of broken tree trunks that absorbed deadly fragments. The dead included MAJ Charles Watters, a 40-year-old Catholic priest who served as the battalion’s chaplain. Earlier in the battle, Watters had ventured out past the perimeter several times to rescue wounded soldiers, carrying or dragging them to safety, providing first aid and administering last rites to the dying—actions for which he was later awarded the Medal of Honor. After witnessing what happened below, a crewman on a U.S. Air Force AC-47 “Spooky” gunship flying in a slow circle 3,000 feet above the dead and wounded troops tossed parachute flares out the back of the plane to help survivors on the ground see in the darkness. A January 1968 U.S. Air Force investigation into the incident was inconclusive, declaring that “there is insufficient evidence to determine the exact cause of the short round” before blaming “improper release conditions.” The investigator recommended that pilots undergo remedial training and that the investigation be closed, as it had revealed “no gross personnel errors nor evidence of equipment malfunction.” [From coffeltdatabase.org and “The Secret History of a Vietnam War Airstrike Gone Terribly Wrong” by John Ismay, nytimes.com, January 2019]

NOTE: Chaplain Watters was the nephew of Navy Boatswain’s Mate Second Class John James Doran, who received the Medal of Honor in the Spanish-American War.

Photo of John J. Doran courtesy of the Congressional Medal of Honor Society

Seton Hall Preparatory High School, West Orange, New Jersey, Class of 1945 yearbook



Citation to accompany the award of the Medal of Honor

AWARDED FOR ACTIONS DURING: Vietnam War
Service: Army
Battalion: 173d Support Battalion
GENERAL ORDERS: Department of the Army, General Orders No. 71 (November 20, 1969)

The President of the United States of America, in the name of Congress, takes pride in presenting the Medal of Honor (Posthumously) to Major (Chaplain) Charles Joseph Watters (ASN: 0-3139624), United States Army (Reserve), for conspicuous gallantry and intrepidity at the risk of his life above and beyond the call of duty while serving with Company A, 173d Support Battalion, 173d Airborne Brigade, in action against enemy aggressor forces in an assault on Hill 875, Dak To, Kontum Province, Republic of Vietnam, on 19 November 1967. Chaplain Watters was moving with one of the companies when it engaged a heavily armed enemy battalion. As the battle raged and the casualties mounted, Chaplain Watters, with complete disregard for his safety, rushed forward to the line of contact. Unarmed and completely exposed, he moved among, as well as in front of the advancing troops, giving aid to the wounded, assisting in their evacuation, giving words of encouragement, and administering the last rites to the dying. When a wounded paratrooper was standing in shock in front of the assaulting forces, Chaplain Watters ran forward, picked the man up on his shoulders, and carried him to safety. As the troopers battled to the first enemy entrenchment, Chaplain Watters ran through the intense enemy fire to the front of the entrenchment to aid a fallen comrade. A short time later, the paratroopers pulled back in preparation for a second assault. Chaplain Watters exposed himself to both friendly and enemy fire between the two forces in order to recover two wounded soldiers. Later, when the battalion was forced to pull back into a perimeter, Chaplain Watters noticed that several wounded soldiers were lying outside the newly formed perimeter. Without hesitation and ignoring attempts to restrain him, Chaplain Watters left the perimeter three times in the face of small arms, automatic weapons, and mortar fire to carry and to assist the injured troopers to safety. Satisfied that all of the wounded were inside the perimeter, he began aiding the medics–applying field bandages to open wounds, obtaining and serving food and water, giving spiritual and mental strength and comfort. During his ministering, he moved out to the perimeter from position to position, redistributing food and water, and tending to the needs of his men. Chaplain Watters was giving aid to the wounded when he himself was mortally wounded. Chaplain Watters’ unyielding perseverance and selfless devotion to his comrades was in keeping with the highest traditions of the United States Army.


From the Knights of Columbus
By Joseph Pronechen  |  May 1, 2024

Father Charles J. Watters celebrated his last Mass on November 19, 1967, on a bright Sunday morning deep in the central highlands of South Vietnam. Vested in a camouflage poncho liner, the U.S. Army chaplain stood at an altar constructed of C-ration boxes at the base of Hill 875 near the village of Dak To. A larger than usual number of paratroopers from the 2nd Battalion, 503rd Infantry Regiment, 173rd Airborne Brigade — known as Sky Soldiers — were in attendance.

“It was an exceptionally good turnout,” recalled Robert Fleming, Delta Company’s radio operator. “Because everyone knew what we were getting into that day.”

John Berry, also of D Company, later described Father Watters’ demeanor: “He usually was in his typical East Coast fast-talk mode. [At] the services he performed the morning we went up on 875, he was unusually slow and deliberate. In retrospect, it was almost like he had knowledge of what was going to happen.”

After Mass, approximately 300 paratroopers from Alpha, Charlie, and Delta companies received orders to attack and seize Hill 875 from a regiment of 2,000 North Vietnamese Army soldiers. The fight for Hill 875 was the culminating encounter of the Battle of Dak To, a nearly monthlong series of engagements with the NVA for control of the region.

On November 19, one of the bloodiest days for American troops in the Vietnam War, Father Watters repeatedly ran unarmed and exposed through front-line gunfire to care for and evacuate numerous wounded men. At dusk, a Marine fighter-bomber mistakenly dropped a bomb directly upon Company C’s command post and aid station halfway up Hill 875. More than 40 men were killed, including Father Watters.

For his actions that day, Chaplain Watters, who was a member of Regina Council 1688 in Rutherford, New Jersey, was posthumously awarded the Medal of Honor — becoming one of only five chaplains to receive the accolade since the Civil War.

Born to be an Airborne Priest

Charles Joseph Watters was born into a devout Catholic family in Jersey City, New Jersey, on Jan. 17, 1927. The youngest of three boys (a younger sister died of polio at age 6), he loved to play baseball with his brothers, Kenneth and Edward, and the other kids on the block. He was also drawn to the priesthood at a young age.

After two years of study at Seton Hall University, Watters entered Immaculate Conception Seminary in Darlington, New Jersey, and was ordained in 1953 for the Archdiocese of Newark. His first assignment as a priest was at St. Mary’s Church in Rutherford, where he joined the Knights of Columbus. He later served, among other assignments, at St. Michael Church in Cranford.

Ed Nestor, a member of Cranford Council 6226 who served Father Watters’ Masses as a boy, remembers him as a quiet, humble priest who was “always active with the CYO kids in the gym.”

Father Watters’ love of flying led him to become a private pilot. He joined the New Jersey Air National Guard in 1962 and soon became its chaplain.

When the Vietnam War ramped up in 1965, 38-year-old Father Watters volunteered as a chaplain with the U.S. Army. After completing the rigorous Airborne training, he was assigned to the Support Battalion of the 173rd Airborne Brigade and, in June 1966, began a 12-month tour of duty in Vietnam.

His family recalls that the priest, who enjoyed photography, brought a camera on his deployment and joked that if he were ever in a battle, he would hold it up and yell, “Tourist!”

In reality, Father Watters regularly served the brigade on the front lines, where he believed he was most needed, and his reputation for staying with units in combat became something of a legend. On Feb. 22, 1967, he took part in the only mass combat jump of the war, parachuting to earth with the 2nd Battalion, 503rd Infantry, as part of Operation Junction City. Five months later, he received a Bronze Star with a “V” for valor for administering last rites to a fatally wounded man under heavy fire.

“When he came home from his first tour of duty, he couldn’t wait to get back to ‘his boys,’” his late brother Ken, a longtime Knight, once recalled.

Soon enough, Father Watters volunteered for a six-month extension and was back with the 173rd.

According to Wambi Cook, Alpha Company’s radio operator and currently president of the 173rd Airborne Association, Father Watters didn’t resign himself to staying in the base camps.

“He felt more comfortable out there with the troops,” Cook said. “I’m not Catholic, but I can assure you that half the attendees at any of his Masses were non-Catholics. I can hear his voice now, calling out. He walked through the lines, beckoning all the guys to Mass — and he always had a good turnout.”

Twenty to 30 soldiers usually came to daily Mass, but on the morning of Nov. 19, nearly 100 men answered Father Watters’ call to worship.

‘He was omnipresent’

As they fought their way up Hill 875 later that day, the battalion was soon immersed in a barrage of machine gun, mortar, and rocket fire from the entrenched North Vietnamese Army. Disregarding danger, 40-year-old Father Watters constantly moved through the lines, on the lookout for those in need of help.

“He was omnipresent, always mobile,” Cook said. “How the Padre managed to embed himself in every conceivable location within our ranks is beyond my comprehension.”

The citation for his Medal of Honor gives a sense of just how mobile Father Watters was that day. It describes him moving among, as well as in front of, the advancing troops — giving aid to the wounded, assisting in their evacuation, and administering last rites to the dying. It also describes the chaplain risking his life repeatedly to rescue fellow soldiers:

“When a wounded paratrooper was standing in shock in front of the assaulting forces, Chaplain Watters ran forward, picked the man up on his shoulders, and carried him to safety. As the troopers battled to the first enemy entrenchment, Chaplain Watters ran through the intense enemy fire to the front of the entrenchment to aid a fallen comrade. …

“Later, when the battalion was forced to pull back into a perimeter, Chaplain Watters noticed that several wounded soldiers were lying outside the newly formed perimeter. Without hesitation and ignoring attempts to restrain him, Chaplain Watters left the perimeter three times in the face of small-arms, automatic-weapons, and mortar fire to carry and to assist the injured troopers to safety.”

As the sun began to set that day, Cook saw Father Watters ministering to soldiers within the tight perimeter: “I can recall him calling out, probably talking to guys personally. He was attending to the wounded. I know that was his modus operandi.”

John Berry of D Company ran into Father Watters as he returned from the front lines.

“As he passed by, we asked him where his helmet was. His reply was, ‘I carry my protection a little higher.’ With that, he was off to attend to the wounded. That was the last time I saw him.”

Among the last people to speak with Father Watters was radio operator Robert Fleming. He was digging a foxhole at the command post when Watters arrived just before 7 p.m.

“Father came in and said, ‘Hey, Bob, throw me my rucksack.’ It was right next to me, so I pitched it to him,” Fleming recalled. “Then he sat down and started eating his C-rations, because he hadn’t eaten all day, and I went back to my digging.”

“The next thing I heard was a loud bang, and I saw a flame front come at me that enveloped my whole body, and then I was unconscious.”

Fleming somehow survived the blast, caused by a 250-pound bomb mistakenly dropped on the command post by an American pilot. It was among the worst “friendly fire” incidents of the war, killing 42 military personnel and wounding 45.

Once word got out that Chaplain Watters was among the KIAs, paratroopers immediately started saying that he deserved the Medal of Honor.

“Probably 90% of those of us who survived and knew Father Watters submitted his name for the award,” Cook affirmed.

Honoring a holy chaplain

Army Major Charles Joseph Watters was buried with full military honors in Arlington National Cemetery. Kenneth and Edward Watters received the Medal of Honor on their brother’s behalf from Vice President Spiro Agnew in Washington, D.C., on November 4, 1969.

Other honors followed. The U.S. Army Chaplain Center and School at Fort Jackson, South Carolina, renamed its building Watters Hall. Fort Bragg in North Carolina named a building the Watters Family Life Center in honor of the chaplain. In the chaplain’s hometown of Jersey City, a public school was renamed Chaplain Charles J. Watters School. About a dozen Knights of Columbus councils and assemblies are named in his honor as well.

With support from Cranford Council 6226, St. Michael’s Parish placed a granite memorial monument in front of the church honoring their former priest.

Eleven years ago, a parishioner suggested honoring Father Watters with a float in the local Memorial Day parade. The council borrowed a chasuble and a uniform and created a tableau on the back of a pickup truck that depicts Father Watters celebrating Mass before a kneeling soldier. The float has been a council tradition in every parade since 2013.

“Father Watters needs to be remembered for what he did, and in our small way here in Cranford, we try to keep his memory alive every year with our commemorative float,” explained Past Grand Knight John Doolan. His sons, Johnny and Bill, now members of the council, portrayed the priest and the soldier several times.

A few days before the 50th anniversary of Father Watters’ death, a Sky Soldier from A Company, 2nd Battalion, named William Heath, left a note for the chaplain on the Wall of Faces, a website sponsored by the Vietnam Veterans Memorial Fund.

“I was at your final service on that eerie, quiet morning before going up Hill 875,” Heath wrote. “Your smile, positive attitude, and dedication to us have been a permanent inspiration for me. It will be 50 years this Nov. 19th since I received Communion on that deadly day. Father, for 50 years I have remembered you when I receive Communion. I thank God for you being with us when you did not have to be there.”

There is no doubt that the chaplain’s selfless actions that fateful day saved lives and saved souls. The news of his death was devastating for those who survived, according to those who personally testified to Father Watters’ bravery.

“Father Watters was a symbol of God and of good to the 2nd Battalion,” wrote a platoon leader in the 173rd Airborne Brigade. “We lost many good men on Hill 875, but we lost more than a man in losing Father Watters.”


From vvmf.org by Chuck Huller, March 31, 2024

Father Watters and I were in the same stick at jump school in ’65. He was 21 years older than me, and one could feel his courage then. We made our 1st jump together when we were at Campbell, which was a night jump, and it was the roughest weather I ever experienced, because of all of the brass on the plane, which was a 124, and we jumped even after the head came off the wind dummy. We just looked at each other and slightly shook our heads.

I ran into him at our base camp in Bien Hoa, and we both remembered those tough days at jump school and laughed hard reminiscing about that night jump when he put my chute on upside down and Capt Walt Rosso screamed at both of us without realizing he was crushing at a Catholic Priest as he roughly took my shoot off and put it on the right way. We both thought Capt Rosso was going to beat us up; he was so angry. This was my first experience with Captain Rosso, who was my OC at Campbell, and he proved to be the best professional soldier I had the privilege to serve with in my 10 years in the service, with 6 years in Asia.

Walt Rosso was like a strict father to me, and we remained good friends for decades. At the last 173rd reunion in Nashville, Walt was in the hospital in serious condition, and I spent an hour with him, and we both remembered that night jump, and we both laughed because he thought Father Watters was a private. Father Watters made his family and friends proud of him. He made our Airborne Corps and the American people proud of him, and he’s made God Almighty proud of him. When I heard that he was killed in action at the end, I openly cried.

Chuck Huller
1/501 101st Airborne (Geronimo Battalion) 65-66
4/503rd 173rd Airborne Brigade
Geronimo battalion


Honorary naming and memorials

The bridge on Route 3 in New Jersey spanning the Passaic River between Clifton and Rutherford has been named in honor of Chaplain Watters.


Public School No. 24 in Jersey City was named after him.


Chaplain Charles J Watters Center in Fort Campbell, Kentucky.


Memorial located at St. Michael’s Church, 501 North Church Road, Cranford, New Jersey, commemorating his service to the parish and for receiving the Medal of Honor.


Buried at Arlington National Cemetery, 1 Memorial Avenue, Arlington, Virginia; Section 2; Grave E-186-A. Photo from ancexplorer.army.mil.


END

CAPTAIN MORTON HAROLD SINGER; U.S. ARMY

DOB/DOD: October 25, 1936 (Flushing, NY) – December 17, 1968; 32 years old
RELIGION: Jewish (Orthodox)
MARITAL STATUS: Married Eva Fischmann (1945-2001) on August 11, 1963.
CHILDREN: Two daughters, Vera Singer Silberberg (1964-) and Karina (1967-).
COLLEGE: Attended Yeshiva Tiferet in Jerusalem; ordained in 1965.
SERVICE NUMBER: O-2334760
ENLISTMENT: Commissioned on September 24, 1967
MILITARY OCCUPATIONAL SPECIALTY: 5310, Chaplain
TOUR START DATE: November 5, 1968
UNIT: Headquarters and Headquarters Company, XXIV Corps
CASUALTY LOCATION: Quang Tin Province, South Vietnam
ON THE WALL: Panel 36W, Line 37

FAMILY: Born to Benjamin (1897-1952) and Celia “Gladys” Zlot Singer [later, Landau] (1900-1998). Two sisters, Roslyn Singer Putzer (1924-2006) and Sylvia (1927-). Three brothers, Samuel (1929-2009), George N. (1934-1935), and Norman E. [also a Rabbi] (1941-).

OTHER: Collegiate weightlifting champion and captain of the Bronx Union YMCA weightlifting team.

CIRCUMSTANCES: On December 17, 1968, a USAF Fairchild C-123K Provider (#54-0708) from the 309th Special Operations Squadron with 44 persons onboard crashed shortly after takeoff from Chu Lai Air Base after reportedly encountering an engine failure following fuel transfer problems. Three crewmen and nine passengers were killed in the crash. The lost crewmen included aircraft commander Lt Col Richard A. Brown, co-pilot 1st Lt Roger H. Strout, and flight engineer SSgt Jesse J. Bradshaw. The lost passengers were U.S. Army personnel: 1st Lt John A. Blaco Jr., PFC Bradley J. Bourque, Sgt Ramon Castro-Morales, Capt Richard C. Drewes, Capt John K. Hayward, CWO John P. Koob, 1st Lt John D. Krouslis, SSgt Wallace F. Simpkin, and Capt Morton H. Singer. Five other passengers died subsequent to the injuries they received. They included two Marines, Sgt Mancol R. Clifton, who died the following day due to burns he suffered, and PVT George W. Brown, who passed away January 13, 1969, also from burns. The three other lost passengers were soldiers: SP4 Dennis G. Benson, who died December 23, 1968, from burns after being evacuated to a burn unit at the 106th Army General Hospital in Yokohama, Japan; SFC Richard H. Sweger, who died January 2, 1969, from bilateral pneumonia due to his injuries; and SP4 Henry E. Russell, who died May 7, 1969, after spending 135 days at Brooks Army General Hospital at Fort Sam Houston, TX, where he was being treated for burns he suffered over 35% of his body. [From coffeltdatabase.org and aviation-safety.net]


Yeshiva University High School for Boys, New York City, Class of 1955



From Newsday (New York) on January 3, 1969

RABBI WHO SERVED ON LONG ISLAND KILLED IN VIETNAM CRASH

A 32-year-old rabbi who had taught Hebrew school in Great Neck [New York] was killed in Vietnam last week while on his way to conduct Chanukah services for Jewish soldiers.

“He felt he could serve the religious needs of the boys and help them overcome the loneliness they would feel away from home,” a former colleague said yesterday of Rabbi Morton H. Singer of Kew Gardens Hills, Queens. Rabbi Singer, a captain in the U.S. Army Reserve, died December 18 near Da Nang in a plane crash while traveling to the scheduled services, according to a report by the Commission on Jewish Chaplaincy of the National Jewish Welfare Board. He had volunteered for chaplain duty in Vietnam and had been there since November 4. Details of the crash were not available. Rabbi Singer left the North Shore Hebrew Academy of Great Neck in October 1967 to train for the paratroopers, but a back injury forced him out of that service. He was a brown belt karate expert and taught judo and karate, as well as English and social studies, at the Hebrew Academy. “The children here worshiped him,” said Rabbi Ephraim Wolf, dean of the school. “When he taught them physical education, it was to instill in them the feeling of being men who would become upright citizens. He felt that if they couldn’t defend themselves and be physically alert, they couldn’t give their best to their country.” The rabbi’s brother, Rabbi Norman Singer of Williamsport, Pennsylvania, said last night of his brother’s decision to go to Vietnam, “He wanted to do something there. He felt that if Vietnam fell, all those countries would eventually fall.” In a letter to the National Jewish Welfare Board from Vietnam, Staff Sergeant Jerome A. Blumberg wrote concerning Rabbi Singer: “… he was a friend who brought that good feeling of being Jewish to us. He was a true giver, giving of himself, especially to the men in the field.” Rabbi Singer, who also had volunteered for non-combatant service in the six-day Israeli-Arab war in 1967, is survived by his wife, Eva, 23; two daughters, Vera, 4, and Karina, five months; his mother, Mrs. Gladys Landau, and his brother. Burial was on Wednesday in Jerusalem. A memorial service was conducted yesterday at the North Shore Hebrew Academy, following the news of his death. A second service is planned, according to Rabbi Wolf. Rabbi Singer’s wife and children are in Guatemala but plan to travel to Jerusalem later this month to visit the gravesite.


From the Philadelphia Daily News on February 4, 1970

Chaplains’ Award Goes to Rabbi Killed in Vietnam

The Chapel of Four Chaplains last night awarded the Hall of Heroes Gold Medal posthumously to Rabbi Morton H. Singer, who was killed in Vietnam on November 17, 1968. The medal was accepted by Rabbi Singer’s widow during the annual awards banquet held at the Bellevue Stratford. Mrs. Singer journeyed from Guatemala to accept the award. Also present was Rabbi Norman E. Singer, of Williamsport, Pennsylvania, brother of Rabbi Singer, who is buried on a hillside overlooking Jerusalem in the cemetery for heroes of the 6-day Mideast war. The banquet was also the occasion for the creation of a formal organization of relatives of men who lost their lives when the USS Dorchester, a troopship, was torpedoed and sunk in the icy waters off Greenland on February 3, 1943. Officers elected by more than 300 persons present were Donald J. Fiedler, of Liberal, Kan., and Mrs. Dorris Clark Fludd, of Philadelphia, a secretary. The Chapel of Four Chaplains was founded to commemorate the heroic action of four Army chaplains aboard the Dorchester when she went down. They were First Lieutenants Clark V. Poling, Reformed Church in America; Alexander D. Goode, Jewish; John P. Washington, Catholic, and George L. Fox, Methodist. The men helped save more than 200 of the 900 men aboard the ship by remaining calm and passing out life jackets, finally removing their own and giving them to others. The last anyone saw of them, they were standing on the starting deck, their arms linked in prayer.


From vvmf.org, posted February 7, 2001, by Jay Hirsch, 1st Cav, 1968

Captain, Chaplain Morton Singer was a volunteer. He did not have to be in the Army or in Vietnam. He volunteered for the Army and then for service in Vietnam as a Chaplain. He was an Olympic-class weight lifter with the soul of an angel. He is one of 16 Chaplains who lost their lives in Vietnam. He was a nice Jewish boy from New York City who grew up to be a great man serving all people.


From The Record (Hackensack, NJ) on August 4, 2011
By Eric Tucker  |  Associated Press

ARLINGTON, Virginia – Vera Silberberg was almost 4 when her father, a military chaplain, was killed in a plane crash in Vietnam while flying to observe Hanukkah with Jewish soldiers. She grew up reveling in stories about him: Morton Singer, the weight-lifting Orthodox rabbi who

Loved cars, rock-and-roll, and his faith. He was serious in his commitment to help American soldiers worship in wartime. Yet his name — and those of 12 other Jewish clergymen — is absent from monuments at Arlington National Cemetery that honor more than 240 other fallen military chaplains. A new congressional effort backed by Jewish groups and survivors of the chaplains will change that, perhaps as early as this fall. “From his daughter’s perspective, I think it would have been important for him — not really for his own namesake but so everyone who has perished and passed away, they should all have their names equally there,” said Silberberg, a dentist who lives in Sherman Oaks, California. Arlington already is home to three monuments for chaplains: one for those killed in World War I and one each for Roman Catholic and Protestant chaplains who died in various 20th-century conflicts, including Korea and Vietnam. The three sit side by side in an area known as Chaplains Hill, not far from President John F.

Kennedy’s burial site. They were built and dedicated by different groups of benefactors, so no one blames Arlington for the absence of a Jewish monument. A joint resolution sponsored by

former Representative Anthony Weiner and Senator Charles Schumer, both New York Democrats, called for a new plaque similar in size and style to the existing three to honor the late Jewish chaplains. It passed both houses of Congress in late May, just in time for Memorial Day. The 13 Jewish chaplains died from 1943 to 1974, though not all were killed in overseas combat. They include Rabbi Alexander Goode, one of four chaplains who died aboard the Dorchester, a troop ship that was torpedoed by a German U-boat as it carried hundreds of American soldiers across the frigid North Atlantic in 1943. The chaplains, as the story goes, gave up their life preservers and gloves to the shivering soldiers and offered comforting hymns even as the ship went down. More than 600 died. The names of the three other chaplains are all memorialized at Arlington. Then there are Irving Tepper, who died in action in France in 1944 after seeing combat in Tunisia, Morocco, and Sicily; Louis Werfel, known as the Flying Rabbi, who died in a plane crash in North Africa; and Herman Rosen and his son, Solomon, who died in a drowning accident and air disaster, respectively, five years apart. Ken Kraetzer, a bank marketing consultant and the son of a World War I Army officer, noticed the lack of a monument for Jewish chaplains while researching the stories of late chaplains from his alma mater, Providence College. Though not Jewish himself, Kraetzer was startled by the apparent oversight. He alerted the Jewish War Veterans of the United States of America and the Jewish Welfare Board Jewish Chaplains Council, which has helped lead the effort. “I don’t consider it a Jewish cause per se,” Kraetzer said. “This is a chance to honor chaplains, past and present. This group just happens to be Jewish.” Cemetery officials told the organizers they could move forward with a monument provided they raised the money themselves and could produce a complete, accurate list of the fallen Jewish chaplains. They did that by cross-checking research from the Jewish Historical Society with records from the chaplain corps of each branch of service. Sol Moglen, who conceived the idea for a September 11 memorial in Brooklyn and helped develop plans for the Arlington monument, helped lead fundraising. Organizers say they have raised about $50,000 — more than enough, they say, to cover the costs of the work. The monument will stand about 7 feet tall, with a bronze plaque mounted on a granite slab listing the 13 names as well as a Jewish proverb: I ask not for a lighter burden, but for broader shoulders. It will also carry an inscription with the Star of David. There would be space at the bottom for future chaplains, if needed. The plans encountered a hurdle after a leadership change at Arlington, when organizers said they learned for the first time that a new monument at the cemetery would require a resolution from Congress. The resolution had widespread bipartisan support, officials say, but getting it through Congress was arduous. “For the last decade or so, there’s been a feeling by Congress that we shouldn’t just put up a memorial to everything that there is, that there should be some deliberations and thought, so there have been hurdles that we’ve had to jump over, generally speaking,” said William Daroff, vice president for public policy and director of the Washington office of the Jewish Federations of North America, which lobbied Congress.

From TheChaplainKit.com


From The Jewish Veterans Newsletter, Volume 72, Number 4, Winter 2018
By Anna Selman

On the Jewish plaque at Chaplain’s Hill, there reads a name: Rabbi Morton H. Singer, USA, 17 December 1968.  Weeks later, an article appeared in the Jewish Telegraph Agency titled, “NY Chaplain Killed in Vietnam, Buried in Israel”.  Those eight words encapsulated the death of Rabbi Morton Singer.  However, the story of his service and his life is much more remarkable.

Rabbi Morton Singer was born in New York City in 1936.  Little is known about his childhood growing up in Manhattan, but we do know that he was an avid weight lifter in his youth – he was recognized as the Eastern Intercollegiate Weight Lifting Champion of 1959.  He was also very active in Judo, and he would later serve on the Armed Forces Judo Team.

He went to City College of New York for his undergrad, and he later attended Yeshiva University.  After obtaining his rabbinical degree, Rabbi Singer taught at a Jewish Day School for 3 years.  However, according to his nephew, Jeffrey Singer, “Rabbi Singer felt a strong obligation to serve.  He believed that if there were Jews somewhere, he was going to help.

So, during the outbreak of the 6 Day War in Israel, it was only natural that Rabbi Singer signed right up.  During the war, he served as a volunteer in the Bikkur Holim general hospital in Jerusalem.  He would often volunteer to drive the ambulance to evacuate soldiers from the front lines in the West Bank.  It was there that Rabbi Singer found a deep love for Israel, and he promised himself that he would move himself and his family there one day.

After coming back to the States, Rabbi Singer signed up for the US Army, and he went to Chaplain School at Fort Hamilton and basic training at Fort Benning. From there, he went to Fort Sill shortly before deploying the Vietnam in November of 1968.

After arriving in Vietnam, Rabbi Singer was busy conducting Shabbat Services, meeting Jewish soldiers, and preparing for Hanukkah.  It was there that Alan Potkin met Rabbi Singer again: “I had seen him only a few days earlier when he tracked me down at the 95th Evac Hospital in Da Nang, where I had been MEDEVACed in with a severed jugular vein from a frag wound.”

On December 17th, Rabbi Singer geared up to conduct Hanukkah services for Marines stationed at Chu Lai Air Base in the Quang Nam Province.  The flight there was quick and easy.  Rabbi Singer sang songs, ate latkes, and played dreidels with a few Jewish marines.  He packed up his gear, and he went to board his C-123 Fairchild to go home.  Seconds after takeoff, there was an explosion in the plane that left 14 dead, caused by the crew placing the wrong type of fuel in the aircraft.

Marine Corps veteran Tracy Diffin was one of the first responders to the scene. “I was on the Fire & Rescue Crash Crew, and was the first one there. A chopper flew overhead to keep the flames down. It was allegedly bad gas in the craft that took it down. Almost everyone died.  I tried like hell to save everyone I could.”

“Growing up, I was always bothered hearing that my Uncle was killed while going to do a mitzvah (conducting Hanukkah ceremonies), because when a person is going to do a mitzvah, they have extra protection from God.  I received some form of comfort upon learning that it was only after completing the lighting on take-off from Chu Lai that this tragic event occurred,” said Jeffrey Singer, Rabbi Morton Singer’s nephew.

On January 2, 1968, Rabbi Morton Singer was buried on a hillside near Jerusalem today in accordance with his last wish. His body was laid to rest at Har Hamenuchot, a cemetery for the fallen of the Six-Day War. Funeral services were attended by the chief chaplain of the Israel Army’s Jerusalem area command, the military attache of the U.S. Embassy, and relatives who live in Cholon, near Tel Aviv.


Buried at Har Ha Menechot Cemetery, also known as Givat Shaul Cemetery, a hilltop burial ground at the western edge of Jerusalem, adjacent to the neighborhood of Givat Shaul, with commanding views of Mevaseret Zion to the north, Motza to the west, and Har Nof to the south. General Hevra Kadisha section, Block Prushim 8, Area 1, Row 15, Plot 10.

Photo from FindAGrave.com and contributor Jackson Hedrick.

END

CAPTAIN MICHAEL JOSEPH QUEALY, U.S. ARMY

DOB/DOD: September 11, 1929 (New York, NY) – November 8, 1966; 37 years old
RELIGION: Roman Catholic
MARITAL STATUS: Unmarried
COLLEGE: Maryknoll Seminary in Ossining, New York. Ordained in 1965.
SERVICE NUMBER: O-2319698
ENLISTMENT: 1965
MILITARY OCCUPATIONAL SPECIALTY: 5310, Chaplain
TOUR START DATE: June 13, 1966
UNIT: Headquarters and Headquarters Company, 3rd Brigade, 28th Infantry Regiment, 1st Infantry Division
CASUALTY LOCATION: Tay Ninh Province, South Vietnam
ON THE WALL: Panel 12E, Line 43

FAMILY: Born to Michael J. (1901-1976) and Margaret A. McGowan Quealy (1902-1992). Three sisters, Margaret E. (1928-1971), Grace Quealy Callahan (1931-), and Theresa A. Quealy Lavelle (1939-1984).

DECORATIONS: Awarded the Silver Star Medal and Purple Heart Medal.

CIRCUMSTANCES: Killed by small arms fire.




Citation to accompany the award of the Silver Star Medal

The President of the United States of America, authorized by Act of Congress July 9, 1918, takes pride in presenting the Silver Star (Posthumously) to Captain (Chaplain’s Corps) Michael Joseph Quealy (ASN: 0-2319698), United States Army, for gallantry in action involving close combat against an armed hostile force in the Republic of Vietnam. Chaplain Quealy distinguished himself by exceptionally valorous actions on 8 November 1966, while serving as Chaplain with Headquarters and Headquarters Company, 3d Brigade, 1st Infantry Division, on a combat mission in the Republic of Vietnam. Against the advice of senior officers at field headquarters in Dau Tieng, Chaplain Quealy insisted on boarding a helicopter of medics and troop reinforcements flying to the relief of the 1st Battalion, under attack in War Zone C northwest of Saigon. Landing at the battle site, Chaplain Quealy checked at the battalion command post to learn where the heaviest fighting was, and rushed to the field to assist with the wounded and give Last Rites to the dying. He saw one seriously wounded man some distance away from the main group and crawled to his side under intense fire from three enemy automatic weapons. By the time he arrived, the man had died, but Chaplain Quealy administered Last Rites and then noticed another wounded soldier and went to him. While he was kneeling by that soldier’s side, a Viet Cong soldier stepped out from the brush and fired at the chaplain with a machine gun, mortally wounding him in the chest and abdomen. Chaplain Quealy’s extraordinary heroism in close combat against an enemy force is in keeping with the highest traditions of the military service and reflects great credit upon himself, the 1st Infantry Division, and the United States Army.


Illustration by William S. Smith, which appeared with the article by Thomas J. Fleming, in The National Newspaper Magazine, March 26, 1967.


From Time Magazine, November 18, 1966

CHAPLAIN’S DEATH

As a boy, Michael Joseph Quealy of Manhattan dreamed of becoming a missionary in Asia, and it was in Asia last week that he died. Father Quealy, 37, a Roman Catholic priest for ten years, volunteered for duty as an Army chaplain and was shipped out last January to South Vietnam. Assigned to the 1st Division, Quealy — against the advice of senior officers at field headquarters in Dau Tieng — insisted on boarding a helicopter of medics and troop reinforcements flying to the relief of the Big Red One’s 1st Battalion, under attack in War Zone C northwest of Saigon. Landing at the battle site, Father Quealy hurriedly gave last rites to dying soldiers from a platoon of B Company. Just then, a Viet Cong soldier stepped out from the brush, fired at the chaplain with a machine gun. Within moments, Quealy was dead. From his pocket fell his diary; the last entry was a passage copied out from the Gospel according to Matthew: “So will my heavenly Father treat you unless each of you forgives his brother with all his heart.”


PRESS RELEASE: Information Office, 1st Infantry Division, APO 96345
Rel No. 1484-11-66
November 16, 1966

DI AN, RVN, (1st INF DIV IO) – It was a short ride from Soui Da to the battle area, but the fighting was so intense on November 8th that the Dust Off chopper was forced to circle the “clearing” for more than an hour. “When we finally went in,” the pilot remembered, “we were being fired at from three sides. I don’t know how we ever got out. But Father jumped out and helped load on the first wounded. I never saw him again.”

Chaplain (Captain) Michael Quealy of New York City joined the Army in early 1965 because he wanted to serve the soldier who had no time to search for the Sacraments. He knew that if there is no priest to celebrate the Mass, to serve Communion, to hear Confessions, to anoint the sick, then the soldier will go into battle and perhaps into eternity, spiritually unarmed. And Father Quealy did not want that to happen.

Commissioned as a First Lieutenant, Father Quealy underwent training at the U. S. Army Chaplain School, then was assigned to Fort Ord, California. In January 1966, he was promoted to Captain. In June, he was assigned to Vietnam, to the 1st Infantry Division.

Serving with the 2nd and, more recently, the 3rd Brigades, Father Quealy gradually formulated a solution to the question he was forever asking: How can I be sure to be in the right place at the right time? He rode the Dust Off medical evacuation helicopters into the battle area, then, when there was more than one wounded, would jump off into the action, there to help treat and evacuate the wounded, to pray with the injured, give Extreme Unction to the dying, and to console the shaken survivors.

He had seen battle in Operation El Paso, Operation Shenandoah, and, finally, in Operation Attleboro. For him, the battle of November 8 differed only in the way it ended.
“He was talking to the wounded who were lying on litters around the Command Post. Bullets were coming from everywhere, but he kept going from one man to another, doing his job,” said one lieutenant.

“He asked me where the most action was,” a sergeant recalled. “Then I saw him run right down there and start pulling the wounded out. I know at least five of those guys owe their lives to him.”

“The bravest man I have ever seen, said Jack Whitted, the commander of the 1st Battalion, 28th Infantry. A soldier who was near him when he died explained how it was: “There were three machine guns firing at us down in this corner. One of them got Father Mike, and he fell, right on the edge of the battle area.” And so, trying to save a soldier’s life and soul, Father Michael Quealy was killed.

“Greater love than this no man has, that a man lay down his life for his friends.” “As long as you did it for one of these, the least of my brethren, you did it for Me.”


From vvmf.org February 24, 2014 by Eugene Tuttle

My battalion was near Father Quealy’s the day he was killed in Tay Ninh province on November 8, 1966. The terrible news reached me the next day. He had heard my confession in Lai Khe about a month earlier. Young men dying was bad enough, but it seemed like a sacrilege for a priest to be killed while providing comfort to the wounded and dying. I had met him months earlier on my first full day in the field, when, before boarding our tanks and APCs to be sent out as “bait” until reinforcements could rescue us, Chaplain Quealy invited the Catholics among us to join him. He told us that reconnaissance had just confirmed the VC were dug in and waiting for us in the bush. He then draped his stole over his shoulders, reminding us that an Act of Contrition could substitute for confession when one was in immediate danger of death. It was an unforgettably dramatic moment, and the chaplain was an unforgettably kind man. I regret just learning of this opportunity now to pay long overdue homage to him. God bless his soul!


Buried at Saint Raymond’s New Cemetery, 2600 Lafayette Avenue, Bronx, New York; St Joseph Section, Range 29, Grave 13. Photo by Jeff DeWitt.


END

CAPTAIN PHILLIP ARTHUR NICHOLS, U.S. ARMY

DOB/DOD: October 25, 1940 (New London, OH) – October 13, 1970; 29 years old
RELIGION: Assemblies of God
MARITAL STATUS: Married JoAnna Beller (1940-2023) on August 19, 1961, in Kalispell, Montana. JoAnna remarried in 1985 and again in 2000, after her second husband passed away.
CHILDREN: Two sons, Wesley D. (1964-) and Joel P. (1965-). One daughter, Wendalyn Rae (1962-).
COLLEGE: B.A. degree from Evangel College in Springfield, Missouri, in 1962, and a B.D. Degree from Gordon Divinity School, Wenham, Massachusetts, in May 1966
SERVICE NUMBER: 574126494
ENLISTMENT: June 22, 196918
MILITARY OCCUPATIONAL SPECIALTY: 5310, Chaplain
TOUR START DATE: March 6, 1970
UNIT: Headquarters and Headquarters Company, 1st Battalion, 52nd Infantry Regiment, 198th Infantry Brigade, 23rd Infantry Division (Americal)
CASUALTY LOCATION: 12 miles northwest of Quang Ngai City, Quang Ngai Province, South Vietnam
ON THE WALL: Panel 7W, Line 133

FAMILY: Born to Reverend Arthur R. (1908-1979) and Grace G. Jacobs Nichols (1918-1999). Three sisters, Miriam L. Nichols Huling (1937-2023), Lois E. Nichols Berninger (1939-2007), and Gloria R. Nichols Hallberg (1944-). One brother, LeRoy “Roy” A. (1946-).

DECORATIONS: Awarded the Bronze Star Medal with Merit, the Purple Heart Medal (twice), the Army Commendation Medal, and the Air Medal (twice).

CIRCUMSTANCES: On March 18, 1969, the U.S. Army’s 198th Brigade and the 6th Army of the Republic of Vietnam (ARVN) Regiment embarked upon Operation Geneva Park in Quang Ngai Province, RVN, a mission to eliminate the enemy forces within their area of operation while stressing pacification and combined U.S./ARVN operations. On October 13, 1970, a command element of the 198th Brigade was devastated when a member of the B Company, 1st Battalion, 52nd Infantry Command Group detonated a booby-trap while moving to a night defensive position 12 miles northwest of Quang Ngai City. Nine U.S. personnel were killed and six were wounded in the blast. An ARVN interpreter accompanying them was also killed. The explosion was caused by either a booby-trapped 105mm round. Lost in the blast from B/1-52 were commander CPT Robert E. Harper, radioman SP4 Ricks A. Hutson, and infantrymen SP4 Larry A. Walker and PFC Stephen M. Cady; from Headquarters Company (1-52): chaplain CPT Phillip A. Nichols, and medics SP4 Mark I. Gross and PFC Eugene O. Brown; and from D Battery, 1st Battalion, 14th Artillery: 1LT Lawrence M. Sullivan and SP4 Anibal P. Lozada-Vichy. Three medivac “dustoffs” were required to remove the dead and wounded from the field. The seriously wounded were taken to both the 27th Surgical Hospital and the 91st Evacuation Hospital at Chu Lai. [From coffeltdatabase.org and Operational Report, Lesson Learned, Headquarters, 23rd Infantry Division, period ending October 1970]


Homer High School (Alaska) Class of 1958. Photos contributed by Deb Curtis, Librarian at Homer High.


Photos from the 1959, 1961, and 1962 yearbooks for Evangel College



From vvmf.org August 22, 2021 by Mike Archer

Recently, I was contacted by a young man by the name of Joel Nichols. His father was a KIA in Vietnam; we were good friends. His name is US Army Chaplain Phillip Nichols, and he is one man I have no problem talking about. Unfortunately, I am selfish and always say, “Phillip left me, just when I needed him most,” it was even raining, as the song says. But Phillip was just my friend, not my father; I forget that sometimes, Joel Nichols never does. 

I thought Joel and I would breeze through this Q&A, but I was sadly mistaken. It was heart-wrenching and emotionally exhausting. But man, am I glad we had that little chat. Thank you from the bottom of my heart, young man!

In my interview for NPR the other day, after we were finished, I talked to the Gold Star son, Joel Nichols, who asked me questions about his Dad. I told him that being a Gold Star Family member is better than being an Olympic Gold Medal winner. The mediator stopped me from recording it.

I think the mediator understood what I was trying to say, liked it, recorded it, and I’m sure it will be added to our Q&A recording. What I was telling the young man was straight from my heart. Sports is one thing, but losing your father at 5 years old is unmatched. People need to realize stuff like that.

People have said many things to me throughout the last 51 years about Vietnam. I tell them I’m no hero by a long shot; I just got lucky many times.  When it’s no fault of their own, a kid that grows up without a Dad is the true Hero/Warrior/Survivor; remember that, people! That’s tough!

Respectfully, Mike Archer


From U.S. Army Chaplaincy, 1945-1975, by Rodger R. Venzke

One of the “performers” was Chaplain Phillip Nichols, Assemblies of God, serving with the Americal Division. Leaving a civilian church in Bonners Ferry, Idaho, to join the Army Chaplaincy in June 1969, his total military career lasted only 16 months. Arriving in Vietnam in March 1970, he was killed on the evening of 13 October while accompanying men of the 198th Infantry Brigade when a concealed enemy explosive device detonated near him. One of those leaders who had to face the challenges referred to by Chaplain Stegman was Nichols’ brigade commander. “Phil’s absence will be keenly felt by all in the Brigade,” wrote Colonel William R. Richardson to Mrs. Nichols. “I admired him for his continuous efforts to go to the field, in spite of inherent dangers, in order to be with the men of his battalion and to provide them spiritual assistance… his compassion for his men endeared him to every soldier, making his death a shocking experience for all of us.”


Buried in Conrad Memorial Cemetery, 641 Conrad Drive, Kalispell, Montana; Section K, Lot 62, Grave 6.

Photo from FindAGrave.com and contributor Carol S.

END

MAJOR ALOYSIUS “AL” PAUL MCGONIGAL, U.S. ARMY

DOB/DOD: November 8, 1921 (Philadelphia, PA) – February 17, 1968; 46 years old
RELIGION: Roman Catholic (Jesuit)
MARITAL STATUS: Unmarried
COLLEGE: Woodstock College, Woodstock, Maryland. Ordained on June 23, 1953.
SERVICE NUMBER: O-4070348
ENLISTMENT: 1957
MILITARY OCCUPATIONAL SPECIALTY: 5310, Chaplain
TOUR START DATE: October 26, 1967
UNIT: I Corps Advisory Group, Hue, Advisory Team #1. With the 5th Regiment, 1st Marine Division, when he was killed
CASUALTY LOCATION: Hue, Thua Thien Province
ON THE WALL: Panel 39E, Row 75

FAMILY: Born to John F. (1882-1960) and Mary E. Baylie McGonigal (1884-1929). Sisters Maria C. McGonigal Phalan (1913-2007), Sister Margaret F. [a nun] (1915-2002), Rose Letitia [a nun] (1916-2013), and Ann Regina “Jean” McGonigal Barry (1924-2019). Brothers John J. (1910-1993), Francis J. (1917-1963), James A. (1923-1995), and Edward J. “Gooch” (1926-1995).

DECORATIONS: Awarded the Silver Star Medal and the Purple Heart Medal.


St. Joseph’s Prep yearbook Class of 1940


1957 Loyola Blakefield Jesuit School, Towson, Maryland, faculty photo


Citation to accompany the award of the Silver Star Medal

The President of the United States of America, authorized by Act of Congress July 9, 1918, takes pride in presenting the Silver Star (Posthumously) to Major (Chaplain’s Corps) Aloysius Paul McGonigal (ASN: O-4070348), United States Army, for gallantry in action involving close combat against an armed hostile force in the Republic of Vietnam. Chaplain McGonigal distinguished himself by exceptionally valorous actions from 15 to 17 February 1968, while serving as Chaplain with Advisory Team 1, Military Assistance Command, Vietnam, on a combat mission in the Republic of Vietnam. During the battle for Hue City, Chaplain McGonigal learned that the Marines of the 1st Battalion, 5th Marine Regiment, were without a chaplain and would be tasked with crossing the river under heavy fire to storm the walls of the enemy-controlled Citadel. After obtaining permission to join these Marines, he went into battle with them for three days of intense urban warfare, consoling the wounded and administering Last Rites to the dying. Chaplain McGonigal’s extraordinary heroism in close combat against an enemy force is in keeping with the highest traditions of the military service and reflects great credit upon himself and the United States Army.


From army.togetherweserved.com: He extended his tour for a second year at the U.S. Advisory Compound in Hue, beginning his tour on 26 October 1967. It was during the Battle of Hue at the Citadel that he went out across the Perfume River and joined with the 1st Battalion, 5th Marines, serving as their priest. On the third day, he was shot in the head while giving Last Rites, on 17 February 1968. He died of that wound. Father McGonigal was not an official member of the 5th Marines but was there of his own power and despite warnings regarding his safety. He was 46 years of age. In 1992, the Marines named the Chapel at Camp Pendleton, California, in his honor.


From VirtualWall.org, posted on April 2, 2007

I met Father McGonigal when I was a Freshman at Georgetown (Class of 1964). I was doing very badly in Freshman math (required course – I was an English Major), and Father McGonigal was kind enough to tutor me in preparation for the final. I survived with a “C” – for me equivalent to an A+ – and was able to continue and complete my four years at GU. The next time I ran into Father McGonigal was in III Corps just prior to Tet in 1968. (I was then attached to MACV, rank of 1st Lieutenant) The occasion was a field Mass at which he officiated and conducted a General Confession as part of the service. We spoke over coffee afterward, and it was very reassuring to me to know he was there. It was to be my last contact with him as Tet broke out a few days thereafter, and we went our separate ways. When I heard of his death, I was profoundly saddened, and I remember him each year on the anniversary of that campaign – and thank him for enabling me to get over the Freshman math hurdle without whose help I’d still be trying to pass that course!

From a student and friend,
Michael P. Shea


Researched and written by Bob McNulty, May 21, 2020. Used with permission.

Chaplain (Major) Aloysius (Al) Paul McGonigal S.J. was born into a large, devout Irish-Catholic household in Tacony on November 8, 1921. His family lived at 6323 Torresdale Avenue along the southern fringe of St. Leo’s Parish from 1916 until 1960. Al’s parents were John F. McGonigal, a 27th District patrolman, and Mary Ellen Baylie McGonigal. Mary Ellen gave birth to twelve children during their twenty-year marriage, nine living and three stillborn. Sadly, she bled to death at age 44 while giving birth to a stillborn son on February 22, 1929.

Even before he started first grade at St. Leo’s Parochial Elementary School (Keystone and Unruh), Al knew that he wanted to be a Jesuit priest. Two of his older sisters also had a religious calling: Margaret (Daughters of the Heart of Mary) and Eleanor (Sisters of Saint Joseph). In the early and mid-1930s, Al and his younger brother Jimmy (also a student at St. Leo’s) would walk three miles every Sunday to their mother’s grave in St. Dominic’s Cemetery (on the 8500 block of Frankford Avenue). Before returning home, Al always stopped first for prayers at St. Dominic’s Church.

Despite his diminutive height (5’4″), Al enjoyed sports and was a fierce competitor. He played baseball, basketball, tennis, and was a strong swimmer. After graduating from St Leo’s in 1936, more than anything, he wanted to continue his education at St. Joe’s Preparatory School (17th and Stiles). Al asked for the Blessed Mother’s intercession and vowed to refrain from swimming for two years. His prayers were heard and, true to his word, despite family vacations to Wildwood in 1936 and 1937, Al did not even put one toe into the water. To pay for his schoolbooks, he sold soft pretzels on the southeast corner of Torresdale and Levick.

Al was a member of the track team at St. Joe’s Prep and was the manager of the crew team. He graduated on June 14, 1940. On October 26, 1987, the Philadelphia Daily News mistakenly listed North Catholic as his high school alma mater, and others have since misprinted the error. Nevertheless, Al was a Hawk, not a Falcon.

Six weeks after graduating from St. Joe’s Prep, Al entered the St. Isaac Jogues Jesuit Novitiate at Wernersville, Pennsylvania. His older brother Frank had a notion that perhaps he, too, had a calling to the Cloth and went along with Al. The Lord, though, had other plans for Frank, who left the novitiate in December 1941 after the Japanese bombed Pearl Harbor. He enlisted in the Coast Guard and was soon thereafter assigned to a patrol boat protecting Cramp’s Shipyard on the Delaware River in Port Richmond.

Al was ordained on June 23, 1953, at Woodstock College, a Jesuit Seminary (closed 1974) near Baltimore. He continued his education at Fordham and Georgetown Universities, earning a master’s degree in physics. During those years, Al had two assignments. First, at Gonzaga College High School in Washington, D.C., as the prefect of studies (earning a reputation as a stern disciplinarian), and then as an instructor at Loyola High School (now Loyola Blakefield) in Towson, Maryland (teaching religion, mathematics, Latin, and physics).

In October 1961, Al joined the U.S. Army as a chaplain (Captain) with the 1st Cavalry Division stationed on the Imjin River in Korea. After completing his enlistment, he returned home in 1963. His brother Frank had died suddenly earlier that year, and Al wanted to be there to comfort his loved ones. For the extended McGonigal Family, the highlight of every Christmas season was when “Uncle Al” would come home for a visit. He adored his nephews and nieces and cherished every moment that he spent with them.

In 1966, Al was working on obtaining a doctorate in physics from Georgetown when his superiors decided to send him to the Jesuit missions in India. Al instead volunteered to go to Vietnam, where he felt he could do the most good. He arrived in Vietnam in December 1966, assigned to the 1st Infantry Brigade, 9th Infantry Division. Expected by his commanding officers to stay in the rear, Al frequently strayed out to the front lines. His calm, fearless demeanor during the thickest of battles won him the love and respect of everyone who witnessed him going about his work.

In 1967, Al extended his enlistment and was granted one week’s leave, which he spent in Ireland. Upon his return to Vietnam, he was reassigned to the U.S. Advisory Compound in Hue. His duties there were minimal, saying two or three masses each week, which left him time to scour the northern provinces for those in need of spiritual succor. Al was in the north on January 31, 1968, when the Viet Cong captured Hue at the start of the Tet Offensive and had to make his way back with a Vietnamese Airborne unit.

By then, combined elements of the U.S. armed forces and the Army of the Republic of Vietnam had retaken most of the southern portion of the city. However, the Viet Cong still controlled the northern half (above the Perfume River), which included the ancient walled Imperial Citadel.

Upon his return to Hue, Al received orders to report to Da Nang for a desk job. He was to leave as soon as southern Hue was secured, and until then, he was to remain in the safety of the advisory compound. The fight for the city was fierce. Fought at close quarters, house to house, the casualties were high. Al ignored his orders and tended to his flock on the battlefield.

On February 11, Al learned that the Marines of the 1st Battalion, 5th Regiment were without a chaplain and that soon they would be tasked with crossing the river under heavy fire to storm the massive walls of the Citadel. Al asked his commanding officer, Lieutenant Colonel Bruce Petree, for permission to go along with them. Petree balked at first but changed his mind after Al pestered him for three days, insisting that his place was with the men fighting on the front line.

With a .45 pistol strapped to his side, Al followed the Marines through the gates of hell. For three days, during intense urban warfare, he stayed with them, administering the last rites to the dying and consoling the wounded.

On February 16, John Olson, an Army combat photographer for Stars and Stripes, captured Al in action, praying over a soldier who had just died from his wounds. Within twenty-four hours, Al, too, was dead. A search party found him the following day in the rubble of a bombed-out house two blocks from the front line; he had been shot at close range in the back of his head.

Ten days after his death, Al was back home in Philadelphia. His viewing and funeral took place on March 1st and 2nd at the Church of the Gesu (next to St. Joe’s Prep). He was then interred at the Jesuit Novitiate in Wernersville.

Major Robert H. Thompson, the commanding officer of the 1st Battalion, 5th Marines, wrote the following letter to the Philadelphia Daily News, published March 20, 1968:

“In the few short days that we spent with him inside the Hue Citadel, I found him to be a man of unshakeable faith and unbelievable courage. Father McGonigal spent every day with the assault companies, administering to the dead and wounded and giving spirit to every Marine who saw him. Without regard to his own personal safety, he continually exposed himself to intense hostile fire to do what he strongly felt was his duty to his God and his Country. Even though he was an Army chaplain, we feel that he belongs to us. The members of the 1st Battalion, 5th Marines who fought in the walled city of Hue, will never forget Father McGonigal, and I’m sure that we will be just a little stronger for having known him.”

Al was posthumously awarded the Silver Star, and his name appears on the Vietnam Memorial in Washington, D.C. (panel 39E/075). In 1989, the Marine Corps named a chapel in his honor at Camp Pendleton. There is also a memorial monument for Al at the Ancient Order of Hibernians Division 17 at 7163 Hegerman Street in Tacony.


From the Philadelphia Evening Bulletin on February 20, 1968

PHILADELPHIA BORN PRIEST KILLED
With Troops at Hue Front

Hue, Vietnam-(UPI)- Leathernecks pleaded with Chaplain Aloysius P. McGonigal not to go up front. But the Philadelphia-born Roman Catholic priest had heard his Marines were going to make a charge into the Communist-infested Citadel of Hue, and he would not stay behind. They found Father McGonigal on Sunday. His body lay in the rubble of a blown-out building, a bullet wound in the back of his head. Officially, Father McGonigal was a Major and a desk man. They gave him an office in the Military Assistance Command Vietnam (MACV) compound in Hue. His chair was usually dusty. The Major with the golden crosses sewn onto his lapels strove to be with U.S. fighting men in Vietnam. The Jesuit would use any means of travel to be with his men. Often, he walked. Sometimes he hitchhiked through some of South Vietnam’s most insecure jungle. “He was a real circuit rider,” said Lieutenant Colonel Bruce Petree, of El Paso, Texas. The MACV deputy adviser said the priest was “never concerned about his personal comfort or appearance.” Father McGonigal, he said, was “rumpled but always on the go.” Last week, he asked Petree for permission to join in the amphibious landing on the Perfume River bank adjacent to the Citadel. “Colonel, would you have any objections if I go out with the Marines?” he asked. Petree asked why he wanted to go. The chaplain told him he felt he could do more up front than in the compound. “Be careful,” said Petree. The Marines tried to stop him. First Sgt. Arcadio Torres, 38, of Mt. Holly, N.J., and a Captain led Father McGonigal into a corner. “We told him that a dead man can’t help people,” Torres said. “But he said his job was to be with the men.” Father McGonigal, 46, entered the Novitiate of St. Isaac Jogues at Wernersville, Berks County, in 1940, after attending St. Joseph’s High School. He was ordained on June 21, 1953, at Woodstock College in Maryland. He was assistant prefect of studies at Gonzaga High School, Washington, D.C., and taught at Loyola High School, Baltimore. Later, he studied physics at Georgetown University. He first served as a chaplain in the Army from 1961 to 1963. He returned to the Army as a chaplain in 1966 and went to Vietnam that year. He was attached to the Maryland Province of the Society of Jesus with headquarters in the Provincial House of the Jesuit Fathers in Baltimore. A letter received at the Provincial House about a week ago reported that Father McGonigal was in Hue and that he felt “pretty safe” because the Marines had the enemy surrounded there. Father McGonigal is survived by three brothers and four sisters. They are James A., of 4529 Teesdale St.; Edward J., of 4527 Aldine St., John, of Newburgh, N.Y.; Mrs. Maria Phalan, of 4404 Cottman Ave.; Sister Rose Letitia, of Our Lady of the Rosary Convent, 339 N. 63d St.; Mrs. Regina Barry, of Metuchen, N.J., and Margaret, a nun with the Daughters of the Heart of Mary, Allentown, N.J. His brother, James, is a letter carrier working out of 9th and Market Streets. His brother, Edward, is a school custodian. His sister, Maria, works for the Penn Mutual Life Insurance Co. The family home was in the 6300 block of Torresdale Ave., Tacony. His father, John F., was a policeman who was attached to the Rising Sun Ave. and Benner St. station when he retired in the mid-1940s. His father died in 1960. His mother, Mary, died on February 22, 1929.


Buried at Jesuit Cemetery, 501 North Church Road, Wernersville, Pennsylvania.


END

CAPTAIN JAMES J.L. JOHNSON; U.S. ARMY

DOB/DOD: June 5, 1933 (Texas) – March 10, 1967; 33 years old
RELIGION: Baptist
MARITAL STATUS: Married to Joyce Elaine Gill (1941-)
CHILDREN: One daughter, Irenée (1966-).
COLLEGE: Graduated from Bishop College in Texas in 1961. Received a Bachelor’s in Divinity from Golden Gate Baptist Seminary in 1965.
SERVICE NUMBER: O-2324354
ENLISTMENT: Entered the service in February 1952 and discharged in December 1957. He enlisted again on January 5, 1966.
MILITARY OCCUPATIONAL SPECIALTY: 5310, Chaplain
TOUR START DATE: September 15, 1966
CASUALTY LOCATION: 2 miles North of Phan Rang, Ninh Thuận Province, South Vietnam
UNIT: Headquarters and Headquarters Company, 3rd Brigade, 4th Infantry Division
ON THE WALL: Panel 16E, Line 53

FAMILY: Born to Anderson (1881-1958) and Neval Burkshire Johnson (1895-1967) [died 4 months after Captain Johnson]. Six sisters, Lucille V. (1917-2003), Reba L. (1919-1998), Estelle (1922-2001), Rozella (1922-?), Thelma (1930-1995), and Ula (1931-?). Eight brothers, Ezekiel “Zeke” (1917-1984), McKinley Sr. (1918-1990), John M. (1921-1957), Anderson Jr. (1924-2011), Walter (1928-), Ottie Lee (1930-2012), Johnny B. (1936-), and Walter Lee (1939-).

DECORATIONS: Awarded the Bronze Star Medal with Merit.

CIRCUMSTANCES: On March 10, 1967, a U.S. Navy VC-47J / DC-3 (#99844) from Tan Son Nhut Air Base Detachment, Naval Support Activity (NAVSUPACT) Saigon, USNAVFORV, suffered a wing failure and crashed into a hillside near Phan Rang while on an administrative Navy flight between Cam Ranh Air Base and Tan Son Nhut Air Base in Saigon, RVN. There were no survivors.

DC-3 tail number 99844. Photo courtesy of AirHistory.net.

From the 4th Infantry Division newspaper “Ivy Leaf” Volume I No. 24, April 21, 1967

MEMORIAL SERVICE CONDUCTED FOR 3/12TH CHAPLAIN

LE THANH – A memorial service was held recently for Chaplain (Captain) James J.L. Johnson (San Francisco) of Headquarters Company, 1st Brigade, who was killed in a plane crash last month. Chaplain (Major) Paschal M. Jackson (Tacoma, Washington), 1st Brigade chaplain, conducted the service. Chaplain Johnson, who has been recommended for a posthumous Bronze Star Medal, was returning from a religious retreat in Seoul when the plane he was riding crashed and burned, killing 25 people. He joined the division last April at Fort Lewis, Washington, arrived overseas with the 1st Brigade in October, and was serving as chaplain of the 3rd Battalion, 12th Infantry. Chaplain Johnson is survived by his wife, Joyce, and a one-year-old daughter, Irenée.



From the National Conference on Ministry to the Armed Forces on March 29, 2021

Chaplain James J. L. Johnson, National Baptist, was a 33-year-old native of Marlin, Texas, who entered the Army in 1965 and joined the 4th Infantry Division in Vietnam one year later. He attended a religious retreat at Cam Ranh Bay in early 1967 and boarded a C-47 aircraft on March 10th to return to his unit. The plane crashed and burned for reasons still unknown. The crew and all passengers, including Chaplain Johnson, were killed.

Chaplain Johnson first joined the military after finishing high school in Texas. He served his country on active duty and active Reserve from 1954 to 1957. After Basic Training at Fort Bliss, TX, Chaplain Johnson served as a Cannoneer at Fort Winfield Scott, CA, and a Personnel Administration Clerk at Fort MacArthur, CA.

In 1961, he received a B.A. degree in Religion and Philosophy from Bishop College (Dallas, TX). Four years later, in 1965, he received a Bachelor of Divinity degree from Golden State Baptist Theological Seminary (Mill Valley, CA).

After being ordained by the National Baptist Convention in 1966, Chaplain Johnson entered the Army Chaplaincy. He was attached to the Chaplain Officer Basic Course at Fort Hamilton. NY, and was assigned to HHC 1st Brigade, Fourth Infantry Division, Fort Lewis, WA.

Chaplain Johnson deployed with his unit to the Republic of Vietnam on September 15, 1966, where he served until his fatal crash six months later. He is buried at Ft Sam Houston, National Cemetery in San Antonio, TX. He is remembered on the Wall of Faces at the Vietnam Veterans Memorial in Washington, DC.

Chaplain Johnson was honored with many awards for his service, including: the National Defense Service Medal, Markman (Carbine) 2nd Class AAA Bar, Vietnam Service Medal, Bronze Star (posthumously) “for meritorious service in connection with military operations against a hostile force,” and the National Order of Vietnam, Fifth Class, and the Gallantry Cross with Palm.


Listed on the Vietnam Memorial in San Francisco, California


Buried at Fort Sam Houston National Cemetery, 1520 Harry Wurzbach Road, San Antonio, Texas; Section Z, Site 183.

Photo from FindAGrave.com and contributor Robert Sage.

END

MAJOR ROGER WILLIAM HEINZ; U.S. ARMY

DOB/DOD: March 11, 1936 (Dubuque, Iowa) – December 9, 1969; 33 years old
RELIGION: Missouri Synod Lutheran
MARITAL STATUS: Married Lois J. Hellwege (1938-), on August 5, 1961, in Stuttgart, Arkansas.
CHILDREN: Two daughters, Deborah Heinz Primerano (1963-) and Deidre “Dee Dee” A. Heinz Thurber (1964-).
COLLEGE: B.A. and B.D. degrees from Concordia Seminary in St. Louis, Missouri. Ordained in the Lutheran (Missouri Synod) ministry on June 4, 1961.
SERVICE NUMBER: O-5501556
ENLISTMENT: September 14, 1964
MILITARY OCCUPATIONAL SPECIALTY: 35310 = Chaplain (Special Forces Qualified)
TOUR START DATE: August 11, 1969
UNIT: Headquarters and Headquarters Company, 5th Special Forces Group
CASUALTY LOCATION: Quang Ngai Province
ON THE WALL: Panel 15W, Line 42

FAMILY: Born to William V. (1909-1987) and Stella L. Nagel Heinz (1911-1994). Sisters Beverly J. Heinz Gerdes (1932-2021) and Sandra L. Heinz Loyer (1943-). One brother, Donald J. (1940-).

DECORATIONS: Awarded the Bronze Star Medal with Valor, a second Bronze Star medal with Merit, and the Air Medal.

OTHER: He was the first pastor of the Lutheran Church in Coventry, Connecticut. He left in July 1964 to join the Army.

CIRCUMSTANCES: On December 9, 1969, a U.S. Army helicopter UH-1H (tail number 68-16220) from Company A, 123rd Aviation Battalion, 23rd Infantry Division (Americal) was conducting a routine shuttle mission for support command when it crashed in bad weather into a hilltop three miles southwest of Minh Long Airfield in Quang Ngai Province, RVN. Three crewmen and three passengers were killed. The aircraft commander survived with injuries. The flight initiated at 7:15 AM from Ky Ha Heliport, where the crew picked up passengers at the Division Administration pad, then departed for Minh Long. Following a change in passengers, the aircraft departed Minh Long in light rain enroute to Ba To. The helicopter was on a heading that would enable it to follow a valley to Ba To after passing through a saddle in a mountain. As the aircraft passed through the saddle, poor visibility caused the pilots to switch to Instrument Flight Rules (IFR). The aircraft commander assumed control of the ship from the co-pilot. He turned left and initiated a climb. After completing his turn, the aircraft commander looked through the chin bubble when he saw the mountainside approaching rapidly. As he attempted to climb over the hill, the main rotor’s retreating blade contacted small shrubs and tall elephant grass on the uphill side of the mountain. As the helicopter continued forward, the skids struck the ground and were sheared off, causing the fuel cells to burst. The main rotor struck the ground and was sheared from the transmission. The tail boom was also severed from the fuselage of the aircraft. Momentum carried the aircraft forward another 150 feet. The destroyed helicopter burned in place; however, it was impossible to determine the exact final resting position of the aircraft because the slope where the accident occurred was approximately 60 degrees, and many of the components rolled down the hill following the fire.

The six soldiers killed in the crash:

    Air crew:

        WO Ward L. Hooper, copilot, Santa Ana, CA (A Co, 123rd Avn Bn)
        SP4 Michael J. McClane, crew chief, Mount Carmel, IL (A Co, 123rd Avn Bn)
        SP5 Edward F. Fratus, gunner, Concord, NH (E Co, 73rd Maint Bn)

    Passengers:

        LTC Karl F. Lange, West Allis, WI (1st Log Cmd)
        MAJ Roger W. Heinz, Coventry, CT (5th Special Forces Group)
        CPT Eugene P. Shumbris, Bayside, NY (HHC, 23rd Div Spt Cmd)

[From coffeltdatabase.org, army.togetherweserved, and vhpa.org]


Images courtesy of Concordia Historical Institute, St. Louis, Missouri.


From “Confidence in Battle, Inspiration in Peace” by the U.S. Army Chaplaincy

Excerpt related to chaplains who deployed to the Dominican Republic during an attempted coup in mid-1965: Among the numerous chaplains who served there, Chaplain Arthur F. Bell, Southern Baptist, recalled that fellow-Chaplain Roger W. Heinz, Missouri Synod Lutheran, seemed to have a knack for ending up in the hottest spots. Returning to his headquarters from conducting a service at an outlying unit one day, Heinz’s jeep was stormed by a stone-throwing mob, which slashed the vehicle’s tires and wounded the driver. Somehow, they managed to escape, and Heinz’s fellow chaplains included a unique, jesting phrase in the day’s incident report: “Chaplain stoned.”


From The Hartford Courant on May 25, 2003

A CHURCH IN COVENTRY

Lois Hellwege and Roger W. Heinz met in St. Louis, where she was working as a nurse and he was training to be a minister. A friend fixed them up on a blind date in 1960. He was tall with dark hair, and she thought he was good-looking. She was blond and peppy and made him laugh.

They fell in love. From the seminary, Heinz was sent to Coventry to establish a Lutheran church. Roger and Lois married and took a month-long honeymoon, driving through the Smoky Mountains, then on to the small eastern Connecticut town neither had ever been to. Roger Heinz went door to door to find Lutherans in the town. Lois Heinz taught herself to play the organ. “We did get the church established with the help of God. It wasn’t easy,” Heinz recalled. While he was in the seminary, Heinz had joined ROTC, and four years later, he got a call from the armed services that they needed him. They moved to Fort Bragg in 1964, leaving behind their new church and friends. Heinz, who never did anything halfway, enrolled in the paratroopers and was always one of the first soldiers out of the plane. Eventually, he joined the Green Berets and left Fort Bragg on August 6, 1969. Lois Heinz walked her husband out to the airplane that would carry him overseas. He kissed his daughters, then 5 and 3, goodbye. “He said he loved me and that he would miss me terribly, the usual things,” Heinz said, wiping away tears as she recalled the last time she embraced her husband. “I had a feeling like I wasn’t that worried about him. We knew he was only going to be gone a year, and his next assignment was Germany. I left it in God’s hands,” Heinz said. Two weeks after he was declared missing in action, Heinz’s remains were found and identified in the burnt remnants of a helicopter that had crashed into the side of a mountain in Vietnam. She wasn’t even sure she could make it through the memorial service at Fort Bragg, let alone raise two children. But when she heard “For All the  Saints” and “A Mighty Fortress Is Our God” being sung by the congregation, her husband’s favorites, she found herself singing along. Her faith in Jesus Christ carried her through the years that followed. “When it first happened, I said ‘Why’ a lot. Then, after a while, I said it was God’s will, so I kicked myself in the rump and said it’s time to start living,” she said. In 1972, Heinz packed up her belongings and moved her family back to Coventry to build a house on a winding country road and return to the

church her husband had helped establish. The first time in the church, she sat behind the organ, put her fingers on the keys, and just began to play. Heinz, now 64, has played every Sunday since, except when she is on vacation. She rarely speaks of the war. “When I moved back up here, nothing was said about it,” she said. “It was such a sore subject.” Then in 1989, she got a call from a classmate of her husband’s who told her about a church youth group that would be visiting the Vietnam Veterans Memorial. He asked her to speak there. “I hemmed and I hawed, and I said, what can I say about such an unpopular war?” she said. When she spoke, she didn’t break down. For the first time publicly, she told the story of how six months after her husband’s death, she received a call from a woman in Ohio who told her Roger Heinz had helped her husband, who was also in the Green Berets, stop drinking. Their last counseling session was hours before Heinz died. A homeless veteran in torn Fatigues who lived in a tent near the memorial shook her hand and hugged her. “I ended up giving my presentation five times,” she said, shaking her head with disbelief that so many wanted to listen to what she had to say. Heinz spoke again in 2002 in Coventry when a replica of the wall came to town, this time about the 612 from Connecticut killed in the war. Heinz, who never remarried, knows her husband lives within their children and five grandchildren. Atop her mantle, she keeps his Green Beret picture, still baby-faced and shy-looking, still in love with her. Sometimes when she is sitting at the organ in church playing, his fae will come to her. “You don’t have much time to think about anything other than your music,” she said. “I’m not saying he’s not there with me. Because I know he is.”


Buried at Arlington National Cemetery, 1 Memorial Drive, Arlington, Virginia; Section 2, Grave E-53-RH. Photo courtesy of ancexplorer.army.mil


END

MAJOR AMBROSIO “JERRY” SALAZAR GRANDEA; U.S. ARMY

DOB/DOD: August 22, 1932 (Corregidor Island, Philippines) – June 13, 1967; 34 years old
RELIGION: Methodist
MARITAL STATUS: Married Jacinta “Jaya” Martinez (1934-2022) on June 10, 1957, in Boston. Jaya joined the Army Nurse Corps shortly after her husband’s death. She eventually married Reverend James Lupton (1933-2007) in 1969.
COLLEGE: Attended Torres High School in Manila, Philippines. Arrived in the United States in 1950 and attended Western Maryland College (now McDaniel College), Class of 1954. Attended Boston University, Class of 1958. Endorsed as a chaplain by the Methodist Commission on Chaplains and entered the Army as a chaplain in 1960.
SERVICE NUMBER: O-2300900
ENLISTMENT: June 13, 1960. Assigned as the base chaplain at Fort Meade, Maryland, and worked with the 69th Signal Corps there. He was then assigned to Fort Campbell with the 101st Airborne.
MILITARY OCCUPATIONAL SPECIALTY: 75310; Chaplain (Airborne Qualified)
TOUR START DATE: November 6, 1966
UNIT: Headquarters and Headquarters Company, 1st Battalion, 14th Infantry Regiment, 25th Infantry Division
CASUALTY LOCATION: Wounded in Vietnam on May 25, 1967, and died in the base hospital at Clark Air Force Base, Philippines, 19 days later, June 13, 1967.
ON THE WALL: Panel 21E, Line 97

FAMILY: Born to Andres G. (1905-1972) and Primitiva Salazar Grandea (1904-1995). Three brothers, Andres “Samuel” Jr. (1930-1991), David (1938-2015), and Exequiel S. (1943-). Three sisters, Estrella Grandea Ocampo (1935-2010), Rachel “Ray” Grandea Abraham (1936-1972), and Elizabeth “Betty” Grandea Mayonado (1941-).

OTHER: Their father, Andres Grandea Sr., started in the Philippine Scouts as a Major. Transferred to the U.S. Army during World War II and is buried in Arlington National Cemetery. A musical family with all siblings playing either violin or piano. Jerry was also a great singer. Upon Jerry’s death, his father donated a portion of his insurance money to buy property in Cavite City, Philippines. 

DECORATIONS: Received the Silver Star Medal, the Army Commendation Medal, and the Purple Heart Medal. In 1972, he was awarded the Hall of Heroes Gold Medal posthumously at the annual banquet of the Chapel of Four Chaplains in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.

CIRCUMSTANCES: Attempting to aid men in battle, he was wounded by multiple fragmentation wounds from mortar rounds on Artillery Hill (Hill 54), 18km Northwest of Chu Lai Airfield on May 25, 1967.


Western Maryland University Class of 1953 yearbook


Boston University Class of 1958 yearbook caption (no picture)


From The Evening Sun (Baltimore, MD) on June 7, 1967
By William Burnett

TWO TELEGRAMS COME FROM VIETNAM

A Viet Cong mortar shell has canceled Jaya Grandea’s plans for a November visit to her native Manila, to be reunited with her husband and start a second honeymoon trip back to Baltimore. The message that changed everything for the diminutive Maryland General Hospital nurse had a terrifying start: “The Secretary of the Army has asked me to inform you that your husband was wounded in Vietnam as a result of hostile action.”

Wounded In Both Legs

“He sustained metal fragment wounds to both legs while he was conducting religious services… mortar rounds…  hospital… treatment…” But the end was reassuring: “He is not, repeat not, wounded.” For this reason, the popular Jaya, real name Jacinta, was glad the Philippine trip was off.

To Be Flown Back

Her husband, Captain Ambrosio (Jerry) Grandea, a Protestant chaplain who trained in 1965 as a paratrooper at Fort Benning, Georgia, was due to be flown back to either Walter Reed or Bethesda Naval Hospital in the next few weeks. “He’s coming home. He’ll be all right now. I can only say I am happy—so happy,” said the tiny R.N. But two days ago, Jaya’s momentary happiness was dashed again. She received a second telegram from the Army. Captain Grandea has taken a turn for the worse, it said, and now is listed in “critical condition.” Mrs. Grandea now sits and waits, hoping and praying for her husband’s recovery. Mrs. Grandea, 33, who lives with her husband’s parents in the 1200 block of Black Friars Road, Catonsville, said her husband’s letters have indicated that, although he was attached to the 71st Evacuation Hospital in Chu Lai, he was trying to be among American fighting men in action as much as possible. He was recommended for a Silver Star, she said, after one exchange of gunfire in which he raced to a wounded man without regard for flying bullets. He called his expeditions with fighting units “humping the jungle with the troops,” she said, but at one point wrote a weary “I wish to God that the war would stop right now.”

Born On Corregidor

Captain Grandea, 34, was born on Corregidor and was living there when the Japanese overran that stronghold and Bataan. His father, Andres, was a member of the Philippine Scouts during World War II and later moved to Baltimore to become an accountant. The elder Grandea, now retired, is a lay leader of Wesley Methodist Church. Captain Grandea was educated at Western Maryland College and the Boston University School of Theology. It was while studying in Boston that he met Jaya, then in training at Boston Lying-In Hospital. They were married in 1957. After serving as minister at two churches in New Hampshire, Jerry Grandea joined

the Army in 1960 and was stationed in Germany during the Berlin crisis of 1962. He left Baltimore for Vietnam last November after preaching a sermon at Wesley Methodist. He is a member, however, of the North Avenue Methodist Church. In his first letter to Jaya after he was

wounded, Captain Grandea used his customary salutation, “My dearest darling.” In longhand obviously made less legible by pain, he stated simply: “I was wounded by shrapnel. No big

thing. Cracked the fibula, so I’m being sent to Japan. Do not worry. Do not cry. The Lord has been so good to us. I love you so much. Jerry.”


Citation to accompany the award of the Silver Star Medal

AWARDED FOR ACTIONS
DURING the Vietnam War
Service: Army
Rank: Captain
Battalion: 1st Battalion
Division: 14th Infantry Division

GENERAL ORDERS:
Headquarters, 14th Infantry Division, General Orders No. 3079 (September 23, 1967)

The President of the United States of America, authorized by Act of Congress July 9, 1918 (amended by an act of July 25, 1963), takes pride in presenting the Silver Star (Posthumously) to Captain (Chaplain) Ambrosio Salazar Grandea (ASN: 0-2300900), United States Army, for gallantry in action while engaged in military operations against an armed hostile force in the Republic of Vietnam. On 6 May 1967, Chaplain Grandea distinguished himself while accompanying Company A, 1st Battalion, 14th Infantry Regiment, 4th Infantry Division on a search and destroy operation near Thanh Hoa. One platoon of the company had been receiving devastating and accurate automatic and small arms fire from enemy forces to the front and flanks, which wounded several men. Chaplain Grandea was with the Command Group when the firing started. As he heard the cries of “medic,” he left the Command Group, which was not receiving fire, and crawled forward to the wounded soldiers. Paying no heed to the heavy volume of fire being directed at the platoon by enemy troops both on the ground and in the trees, Chaplain Grandea moved to each of the wounded and assisted the medics in the administration of first aid. Shouting words of encouragement not only to the stricken men but also to those repelling the attack, he inspired the men of the platoon to fight with renewed vigor and determination. Chaplain Grandea’s courageous actions were in large part responsible for the defeat of the enemy. His unselfish gallantry is in keeping with the highest traditions of the military service and reflects great credit upon himself, his unit, and the United States Army.


From vvmf.org

Courtesy of Exequiel Salazar Grandea:

I want to add to my niece’s description of my late brother’s biography – Chaplain (Major) Ambrosio Salazar Grandea, United States Army, was awarded the Silver Star for Bravery and Valor when he pulled wounded soldiers to safety while under heavy fire in Chu Lai Province. This was two weeks before he was injured by a booby trap that eventually caused him to lapse into a coma three days after the event, and then to his succumbing to those injuries twenty days later in his native land of the Philippines at Clark Air Base. The Department of Defense stated at that time that “Chaplain Grandea’s weakened condition contributed to his demise.”


From “Confidence In Battle, Inspiration In Peace; The United States Army Chaplaincy 1945-1975”

Chaplain Ambrosio Salazar Grandea, Methodist, had moved with his parents from his home in the Philippines Islands to the United States at the age of 18. During postgraduate work at Boston University, he had served a church in New Hampshire before entering the Army in 1960. Arriving in Vietnam in November 1966, he was conducting a worship service for men of the 4th Infantry Division on 25 May 1967 when he was wounded by an enemy mortar round. After treatment in Vietnam, he was evacuated to a hospital at Clark Air Force Base in the Philippines. There, near his birthplace, Chaplain Grandea died only a few days later on 13 June 1967. The chaplain’s wife, Mrs. Jacinta Grandea, working as a nurse in Baltimore, Maryland, had first been informed that his wounds were slight, but each new message carried reports of the growing seriousness of his condition. At her own expense, she left for the Philippines to be with him, but was stopped while changing planes in San Francisco by an officer who informed her of her husband’s death. Six months later, 2 days before Christmas, Mrs. Grandea participated in a dual ceremony at Fort Meade, Maryland, after receiving the posthumous awards of her husband’s

Silver Star and Purple Heart, she was sworn in as an Army nurse. Mrs. Grandea volunteered with the stipulation that she be sent to Vietnam. “We are engaged in a tough war in Vietnam,” she said. “All of us have to do our little bit to end the task with success and honor.”


The road leading to the Base Chapel on Fort Meade, Maryland, is named in his honor.


Buried in Arlington National Cemetery, 1 Memorial Drive, Arlington, Virginia; Section 2, Grave E-186-1. Picture courtesy of ancexplorer.army.mil.


END

LIEUTENANT COMMANDER WILLIAM JOHN GARRITY, JR.; U.S. NAVY

DOB/DOD: September 23, 1926 (Helena, MT) – October 26, 1966; 40 years old
RELIGION: Roman Catholic
MARITAL STATUS: Unmarried
COLLEGE: Attended Carroll College in Helena, graduating in 1949, and St. Thomas Seminary in Denver, Colorado. Ordained on April 4, 1954.
ENLISTMENT: Served June 26, 1944, through September 29, 1950, in the Navy Reserves; service number 5548943. Entered active duty again on October 30, 1957, in Helena, Montana.
SERVICE NUMBER: 622943
NAVY RATE: 4100, Staff Corps – Chaplain
TOUR START DATE: May 1965; he was on his second 7-month tour of duty
SHIP ASSIGNED TO: USS Oriskany (CVA-34), TF 77, 7th Fleet
ON THE WALL: Panel 11E, Line 110

FAMILY: Born to William J. “Jack” Sr. [Army veteran] (1896-1985) and Marion L. Sillers Garrity (1900-1987). One brother, Matthew S. (1929-2017).

CIRCUMSTANCES: On October 26, 1966, there was an aircraft flare fire aboard the aircraft carrier USS Oriskany operating in the Gulf of Tonkin off the coast of Vietnam. Two sailors were re-stowing unexpended MK-24 Mod 3 Flares when one was accidentally dropped. The igniter had not been reset to “safe.” As it dropped, the safety lanyard was inadvertently pulled, actuating the flare. For reasons known only to him, one of the sailors picked up the armed flare, threw it into the magazine locker, and closed the door. Some 2.75-inch rocket warheads loaded with Composition B were stowed in the locker. Shortly after the flare ignited in the locker, the intense heat caused a 2.75 rocket warhead in the locker to detonate, sending fire and smoke into the hangar bay. This was followed by a second warhead explosion that spread fire throughout the entire hangar deck and in the forward portion of the ship. Finally, heat caused a liquid oxygen tank to explode. Before the fires were completely under control, 44 sailors had died (43 from asphyxiation and one from burns) and 156 had been injured. Besides the material damage to the ship, two helicopters and an A-4E aircraft were destroyed, and three A-4E aircraft were damaged. The estimated cost of the material damage was $11 million. The following officers and men of Oriskany died in or as a result of the fires: CDR Jack H. Harris, CDR Richard E. Donahue, CDR Harry W. Juntilla (DOW 10/31/66), LCDR William J. Garrity Jr., LCDR Walter F. Merrick, LCDR Omar R. Ford, LT Frank M. Gardner, LTJG Dewey L. Alexander, LTJG Ramon A. Copple, LTJG James B. Hudis, LTJG James A. Kelly Jr., LTJG Franklin M. Tunick, BM3 Donald W. Shanks, BM3 Alvin M. Shifflett Jr., SN Robert L. Dyke, SN James K. Gray, SN James A. Lee, FN William Walling, AA Greg E. Hart, CDR Rodney B. Carter, LT Lloyd P. Hyde, LTJG William R. Clements, CDR George K. Farris, LCDR James A. Smith, LT John F. Francis, CDR John J. Nussbaumer, AZAN David A. Liste, LCDR Clement J. Morisette, LT Clarence D. Miller, LTJG Thomas E. Spitzer, ENS Ronald E. Tardio, CDR Clyde R. Welch, LCDR Daniel L. Strong, LTJG James L. Brewer, LTJG William A. Johnson, LCDR Norman S. Levy, LTJG Cody A. Balisteri, LTJG William G. McWilliams III, ENS Charles W. Boggs, LT Josslyn F. Blakely Jr., LT Julian D. Hammond Jr., LTJG Gerald W. Siebe, LTJG James R. Welsh, and ENS Daniel O. Kern. [From insensitivemunitions.org and virtualwall.org]


Carroll College (Helena, Montana) 1948 and 1949 yearbook


1965 USS Oriskany Cruise Book
Catholic Northwest Progress November 4, 1966

From The Catholic Standard and Times on November 4, 1966

CHAPLAIN KILLED IN CARRIER BLAZE

WASHINGTON (NC) — Lieutenant Commander William J. Garrity, a Catholic chaplain in the U.S. Navy, lost his life on October 26 in the fire aboard the aircraft carrier USS Oriskany, which claimed the lives of 43 officers and enlisted men, the Department of the Navy announced here. He had served the Oriskany as the ship’s Catholic chaplain since May 1965. Father Garrity, 40, was born in Helena, Montana, where his parents still reside. He attended grade school and high school in Helena and graduated from Cathedral High School in 1944. He served as an enlisted man in the Navy from 1944 to 1946 and was a survivor of the USS YMS-275, which was lost in a typhoon off Okinawa on October 9, 1945. Ordained in 1954, Father Garrity began his studies for the priesthood in 1946. He attended Carroll College in Helena and St. Thomas Seminary in Denver and was ordained in 1954.  Following his ordination, he served as assistant pastor at

Immaculate Conception parish in Butte and at Holy Rosary Church in Bozeman, Montana. He also taught at Holy Rosary High School in Bozeman. Father Garrity received a commission in the Chaplain Corps, U. S. Naval Reserve, in 1957, and went on active duty in 1962. His assignments included U.S. Naval Hospital, Great Lakes, Illinois; First Marine Division, Fleet Marine Force, Camp Pendleton, California; and the USS Oriskany. He was one of several priests and ministers who cared for the injured on the Oriskany after it was damaged by fire in the Gulf of Tonkin. The Catholic chaplain on the USS Constellation, Father (Lieutenant Commander) Roch Larunzana of New York, and Father (Lt.) John Morley of New York, the Catholic chaplain on the carrier USS Roosevelt, along with Protestant chaplains, were rushed to the Oriskany by air.


The USS Oriskany (CV-34) Anchor Monument Plaque is at roughly 405 Utica Street, Oriskany, New York.

Photo credit to HMDB.org and contributor Steve Stoessel of Niskayuna, New York

Buried in Resurrection Cemetery, 3685 N. Montana Avenue, Helena, Montana; St. Joseph Section, Grave 17.

Photos from FindAGrave.com and contributor “A Marine’s Daughter.”

END