ORDINARY SEAMAN JAMES SULLIVAN*; NAVY

* His name at birth was Peter Van Hoesen. He entered the Navy under the alias of James Sullivan at Danbury, Connecticut. He previously served in the 18th New York Infantry, Company B, and the 7th Connecticut Volunteer Infantry, Company H, as a Private.

DOB/DOD: January 24, 1831 (Albany County, NY) – May 10, 1918 (South Bethlehem, NY); 90 years old
MARITAL STATUS: Married Nancy Acker (1840-1875) in 1858. Then married Charlotte I. Mansfield (1848-1908) in 1875.
CHILDREN: Three daughters, Hannah M. Van Hoesen Snyder (1860-1941), Helen J. Van Hoesen Hurst (1867-1942), and Anna Van Hoesen (1872-1875). Three sons, Henry (1863-?), Garret (1865-?), and Peter (1873-?).

FAMILY: Born to John (1795-1860) and Elizabeth Wiedman Van Hoesen (1803-1865). Two brothers, William (1822-1914) and Henry (1836-1913). Two sisters, Elizabeth J. (1837-?) and Catherine (1846-).

OTHER: After his service in the war, Van Hoesen stopped using the alias James Sullivan and tried to file for his veteran pension. He was denied his pension due to his desertion while he was in the Albany Barracks. He died on May 10, 1918, without ever receiving his pension or recognition for the Medal of Honor, and was buried in Coeymans Hollow Cemetery in Albany, New York. His service in the Civil War was mentioned at his funeral, but nothing about his Medal of Honor. On August 27, 2016, ninety-eight years after he died, he was finally recognized as a Medal of Honor recipient by a new tombstone bearing the Medal of Honor marker.


MEDAL OF HONOR CITATION

AWARDED FOR ACTIONS DURING: Civil War
BRANCH OF SERVICE: Navy
ASSIGNED TO: U.S.S. Agawam
GENERAL ORDERS: War Department, General Orders No. 45 (December 31, 1864)
CITATION:
The President of the United States of America, in the name of Congress, takes pleasure in presenting the Medal of Honor to Ordinary Seaman James Sullivan, United States Navy, for extraordinary heroism in action while serving on board the U.S.S. Agawam as one of a volunteer crew of a powder boat which was exploded near Fort Fisher, North Carolina, 23 December 1864. The powder boat, towed in by the Wilderness to prevent detection by the enemy, cast off and slowly steamed to within 300 yards of the beach. After fuses and fires had been lit and a second anchor with short scope let go to assure the boat’s tailing inshore, the crew again boarded the Wilderness and proceeded a distance of 12 miles from shore. Less than two hours later, the explosion took place, and the following day fires were observed still burning at the fort.

Presentation Date and Details: May 12, 1865, off New Bern, North Carolina, on board the U.S.S. Agawam. The others were William Garvin, Robert Montgomery, John Neil, and James Roberts.

U.S.S. Agawam (1864-1867). In the James River, Virginia, July 1864. Photographed by Brady & Company, Washington, D.C. Collection of Surgeon Herman P. Babcock, USN. Donated by his son, George R. Babcock, in 1939. U.S. Naval History and Heritage Command Photograph.

From The Hitching Post, The Newsletter of the Ravena Coeymans Historical Society; Volume 9, Number 2, Summer 2011; Harry A. Sturges

Mr. Donald Morfe, a member of the Medal of Honor Historical Society, contacted me asking for my assistance in locating the burial site of a veteran of the Civil War and possible MOH recipient named Peter Van Hoesen. It was believed that Peter may have been buried in the Coeymans Hollow cemetery, but the society had no actual proof that this was true. Morfe’s organization, a not-for-profit volunteer group, devotes its time locating the burial sites of recipients of the Medal of Honor and thereafter, if it had not previously been done, making sure that an appropriate marker is placed on the graves honoring such heroes. It reads,

“The Department of Veterans Affairs, upon proper application and with ample proof of identity, after themselves doing due diligence to ascertain the information as accurate, will furnish at no cost to the cemetery a marker to be placed on the grave commemorating the serviceman’s designation as a MOH recipient.”

A map of the Coeymans Hollow Cemetery, prepared by the American Legion Post #114 of Ravena, identifies the gravesites of veterans from various wars. Peter Van Hoesen’s site was clearly marked, as well as the graves of 23 other Civil War veterans. The Record of Enlistments prepared by Town Clerk John Whitbeck in 1865 lists 137 Civil War veterans from the Town of Coeymans, including 12 who were in the U.S. Navy, 11 who died from disease (mostly in Louisiana), five who died from combat wounds, two deserters, and one who had hired a replacement.

Van Hoesen’s gravestone contains the following information: “Peter Van Hoesen, Co. H, Regiment 7, Connecticut Volunteers, Died May 10, 1918, aged 86 years.” His wife is buried just to the right of Peter. Her stone reads: “Charlotte Mansfield, wife of Peter Van Hoesen, 1849-1908.” The information on his and his wife’s gravestone seemed to verify that we had found the correct Peter Van Hoesen, as his military record almost perfectly matched the information on his stone. I say almost because the military has his death as May 9, 1918, instead of May 10.

I took several pictures of the gravestones and e-mailed them to Mr. Morfe. He felt positive enough about the identity that he sent me a copy of the VA’s application for a MOH marker. The application was completed with the help of Town Clerk Diane Millious and her staff and with additional assistance from Richard Houghtaling, a town employee working in the Parks Department.

One piece of information missing from Peter Van Hoesen’s stone is the fact that, besides serving in the Grand Army of the Republic, he had also served in the U.S. Navy as an Ordinary Seaman. It was during his naval service that he earned the MOH.

Van Hoesen served aboard the U.S.S. Agawan, which was a wooden, double-ended side-wheel gunboat with a complement of 145 officers and men under the command of Commander Alexander Rhind. She was commissioned on March 9, 1864, and left port on May 6, two days after the Army of the Potomac crossed the Rapidan River to begin General Grant’s offensive against Richmond. This action was designed to place unrelenting pressure on General Robert E. Lee’s Army of Northern Virginia until it was bottled up in the siege of Richmond and possibly forced to surrender. The Agawan performed most of her Civil War service in support of that mission.

Early in July, Lieutenant George Dewey (later Admiral Dewey, the hero of Manila Bay) temporarily relieved the command of the Agawan. It was Lieutenant Dewey’s first command. Commander Rhind left the Agawan for a short time to take command of the Louisiana, a steamer selected to perform an unusual and seemingly important task. Rhind took with him a carefully selected small group of volunteers, including Peter, to man this vessel. The Louisiana was towed to Wilmington, North Carolina, for use as a giant bomb against the fortification at Fort Fisher. I can’t imagine walking atop that steamer’s deck lighting fires and fuses, knowing that any malfunction, one short fuse or one slip, would blow me to kingdom come. The purpose of this dangerous mission was to cause a concussion and/or fire severe enough to detonate the fort’s powder magazine, causing mass damage to the fort and heavy casualties to the enemy. Although fires were reported burning at the fort for several days after the blast, the mission failed in its attempt to cause the more desired results. (The above information was taken from various sources located on the web).

For Peter Van Hoesen’s act of bravery on that day, December 22, 1864, he was awarded the MOH. On May 12, 1865, the medal presentation ceremony took place aboard the Agawan off New Bern, North Carolina.

There are many websites dedicated to the MOH, including one that lists the names of all MOH recipients. You will not find Peter’s name on that list. There is also a site naming all the seamen who served aboard the U.S.S Agawan. You will not find Peter’s name on that list, either. His military record lists his name as James Sullivan, aka Peter Van Hoesen, with a notation “deserted.” There were a million reasons why men from both sides deserted, and there were thousands and thousands listed as deserters who, in fact, never did so. But that is another story. It appears that after James Sullivan completed his military enlistments, he adopted the named Peter Van Hoesen and lived with that name until his death.

I have no personal information of Peter Van Hoesen or his wife, Charlotte. I do not know exactly where his home was when he died, what he did for a living, if he had children, or know why he and his wife were buried in the Coeymans Hollow Cemetery.

I do know that he was an infantry soldier in the Grand Army of the Republic, an ordinary seaman in the U.S. Navy, and a recipient of the Medal of Honor, the highest award for valor in action against an enemy our country bestows. For that, I honor him.


From PorcupineSoup.com, an online digital newspaper, September 30, 2021; Tracing Your Roots in Greene County: Civil War hero Peter Van Hoesen; written by Sylvia Hasenkopf, historian, North River Research.

It was December 23, 1864, a dark, murky night off the coast of North Carolina, when a volunteer crew from the U.S.S. Agawam boarded the U.S.S. Louisiana. They set the fuses and kindled a fire in the aft of the boat, escaping in small boats afterward. The hopes were that the explosion of this “powder boat” would destroy Confederate Fort Fisher or, at the very least, create enough damage that Union soldiers would be in a position to easily take the fort.

For his efforts that night, Ordinary Seaman James Sullivan of the U.S.S. Agawam received a Congressional Medal of Honor on May 12, 1865, aboard the U.S.S. Agawam as it was stationed off New Bern, North Carolina.

The only problem was that James Sullivan really wasn’t James Sullivan at all. His real name was Peter Van Hoesen, who hailed from the Town of Bethlehem in New York.

I first became aware of Peter Van Hoesen when Rick Shanks, the senior vice commander of Ravena Unitas Memorial VFW Post 9594, sent me an email. He advised me that he had been working with the Medal of Honor Historical Society to replace the headstone of Peter Van Hoesen with one noting that Peter was a recipient of the Medal of Honor.

Rick passionately wanted to right a wrong that was done to Peter.

Peter Van Hoesen’s story is one of youthful patriotism, of fear, and of redemption. It’s a tale that has not been told in its entirety before, but one I hope to rectify with this article.

Peter Van Hoesen was the son of John Van Hoesen and his wife, Elizabeth Wademan, of the Town of Bethlehem. According to his Civil War Muster Roll abstract, he was born in Albany on January 24, 1831. He was 5 feet and 5 inches in height, with black hair, dark eyes, and a dark complexion. At the time he enlisted in the Civil War, he was a carpenter.

He was raised in the Town of Bethlehem with his sister, Elizabeth, who was two years younger, and his brother, Henry, who was four years younger, although I have not yet determined exactly where in the Town the family resided.

In the 1850 census, Peter’s father was already aged 55, and Peter’s wife was 47. A young child, Catharine Van Hoesen, aged 4, is listed before Peter and his siblings. I suspect that Catharine may be a second wife and Catharine, her daughter. It is also quite possible that young Catharine is their youngest child or even a grandchild. More research is definitely needed on the earlier days of the family.

It appears that the Van Hoesen family was relatively poor. There is no profession listed for John in the census, nor is there any indication that he owned any real estate. Peter, on the other hand, was already working as a farmer, most likely on someone else’s farm. Only 12-year-old Henry had attended school in the previous twelve months.

I found the Van Hoesen family in the 1855 census, still in the Town of Bethlehem. Peter is no longer in the household, and I was unable to track down his location. By this time, Peter is 24 years old. He may have gone west or was simply working elsewhere. With the name Van Hoesen, one finds numerous spelling variations in all the official documents, which complicated tracking him in the censuses.

Peter married Nancy Acker in 1858 when she was just 18 years old. She was someone he would have known fairly well. She and her parents, Henry and Hannah Acker, are enumerated, with younger children, in the same neighborhood as the Van Hoesen household.

Nancy Van Hoesen, aged 20, appeared in the 1860 census, working as a servant in the household of farmer Stephen Baumer in Bethlehem Center. There is no sign of Peter, and again, I have been unable to locate him in the census. Nancy soon became pregnant, however. Her daughter, Hannah, was born in May 1861.

The national elections in the year 1860 were fractious, with passionate advocates on both sides of the contentious issue of the expansion of slavery to the western territories presenting their entrenched viewpoints.

The Republican platform was clear; they did not support slavery in the western territories and barely recognized the rights of the existing southern states rights to have slavery within their borders.

Abraham Lincoln, a Republican, won the national election that year, which set the southern states on edge. Their cotton-based economies were dependent on the institution of slavery and the cheap field labor it provided.

Before Lincoln could be sworn into office in March 1861, seven southern states, led by South Carolina, seceded from the United States of America to form the Confederacy. Mississippi, Florida, Alabama, Georgia, Louisiana, and Texas joined South Carolina in their defiance of Washington D.C. and the Republican policies of President-elect Abraham Lincoln.

The Civil War began in earnest when Confederate soldiers attacked Fort Sumter on April 12, 1861, a key federal fort on the Atlantic coast in South Carolina.

Peter enlisted in the 18th Infantry Regiment, NYV [New York Volunteers] on April 24, 1861, in Albany for a 2-year term, very likely looking for a steady income for his young family. Peter was mustered into Co. B as a private on May 17, 1861. He was paid $8.48 for the period April 24 to May 17, 1861.

The Regiment left New York State on June 19, 1861, arriving in Washington, D.C., on the 21st. The 18th joined the 2nd Brigade, 5th Division, Army of Northeastern Virginia on July 13th and began the march in search of Confederate forces.

There was a strong belief amongst the northern soldiers that the rebellious southern army would be crushed in their first engagement with northern troops. It was expected to be a short and decisive war. Spirits were high, and the troops, mostly fresh-faced young men, were eager for their first taste of battle.

The 18th encountered the enemy on Braddock Rd., at Fairfax Station, and at Blackburn’s Ford between July 16th and 18th, with minimal casualties and only one death. The first true taste of war was experienced by the men of the 18th on July 21st at the First Battle of Bull Run, also called the First Manassas.

The First Battle of Bull Run has the distinction of being the first battle of the Civil War. The Union army fielded 18,000 poorly led and poorly trained troops against an equally untrained force of Confederate soldiers. Strategic errors on the side of the Union led to a resounding defeat on the battlefield.

As the Confederate Army advanced, Union soldiers panicked, broke ranks, and fled back towards Washington, D.C.

The Union Army suffered the loss of 2,708 soldiers – 481 killed in action, 1,011 wounded, and 1,216 missing. The Confederate Army’s loss of 1,982 soldiers was slightly less – 387 killed in action, 1,582 wounded, and 13 missing. The 18th NYV had seen service that day as support for the artillery units on the field and had suffered no casualties.

The Union Army finally realized that defeating the south would not be as easy as they had originally thought.

Private Peter Van Hoesen was promoted to the rank of Corporal in October 1861.

The 18th regrouped in Alexandria, VA, and established winter quarters were near Fairfax Seminary, where the regiment was involved in the construction of Fort Ward over the winter.

It wasn’t until late June 1862 that the men of the 18th were themselves tested in battle.

The Union Army of the Potomac had marched steadily toward the Confederate capital, Richmond, hoping to force a decisive battle and end the war. Initially, the Confederate Army was led by General Joseph E. Johnson, known as a relatively cautious battle commander. Wounded in the Battle of Seven Pines, Johnson was replaced with the far more aggressive Confederate General Robert E. Lee, who reorganized his troops and prepared for an offensive campaign.

Union Major General George B. McLellan was also well-known as a cautious commander. When faced with the tactical strength of Lee’s Confederate troops, he moved his northern troops into defensive positions, and the Union Army began to retreat down the Virginia Peninsula. Lee’s troops were hot on their trail.

Six major battles, known as the Seven Days Battles (or the First Battle of Cold Harbor), occurred over the period of June 25 to July 1, 1862, near Richmond, VA. The 18th Regiment participated in the battles at Gaines’ Mills, Garnett’s and Golding’s Farms, Glendale, and Malvern Hill.

It was at Gaines’ Mills, however, that the troops of the 18th Regiment experienced their first major casualties. Two officers were killed, along with 17 enlisted men. One officer and one enlisted man died of their wounds.

Over the course of the Seven Days Battles, an additional 3 officers and 58 enlisted men were wounded yet recovered from their injuries. Tellingly, however, 1 officer and 42 enlisted were missing at the end of the last battle.

There is no question that the men of the 18th were in the thick of battle and realized the mortality of their lives.

At the end of the Seven Days Battle, McClellan’s army, which was in full retreat down the Virginia Peninsula, suffered 16,000 casualties. Lee’s army, which had been on the offensive the whole time, lost over 20,000 men.

According to Rick Shanks, Peter Van Hoesen was demoted during the Peninsula Campaign for reasons unknown. He participated in one more skirmish at Burke’s Station, VA, on August 28th before walking away from his regiment on September 6th, 1862, at Alexandria, VA.

We will likely never know the real reason Peter left his regiment. Was he afraid? Was he angry at his demotion? Was he embarrassed to serve with his fellow soldiers after his demotion? Was he simply missing his young wife and baby? Regardless, he walked home to Bethlehem.

Desertion was a hanging offense during the Civil War. Anyone could capture a deserter and hand him over to the authorities. Somehow, local authorities were advised that Peter had deserted. He was captured on July 2, 1863, in New Scotland, NY, not far from his hometown, and was taken to Albany. He escaped his detention three days later, on July 5th, and fled to New York City, where he could be lost amongst the throngs of people living there.

Nancy was pregnant with the couple’s second child, Henry, who was born in December of that year.

Peter could have stayed in New York City for the duration of the war, waiting for the war to end. Instead, a chance meeting with James Sullivan, who had been drafted, changed the course of Peter’s life. James was not interested in becoming a soldier and convinced Peter to assume his identity and enlist on his behalf.

Peter received $300 at his enlistment as James Sullivan, although it is unclear whether James paid him this money to assume his identity or whether this was bounty money paid at the time of enlistment. Regardless, this would have been welcome money for Nancy and the children back in Bethlehem.

Peter traveled to Connecticut, and on October 24, 1863, as James Sullivan enlisted in the 7th Regiment Connecticut Volunteer Infantry, who, with the 7th New Hampshire Volunteer Regiment, formed the 77th New England.

Peter stated in his pension records that his new regiment knew of his subterfuge and his real name, yet no one seemed to be bothered by it.

In April 1864, Peter was transferred to the Navy and was stationed on the U.S.S. Agawam. Was it his guilt for having deserted the 18th Regiment that led Peter to volunteer for the dangerous mission to sink the powder boat, the U.S.S. Louisiana? Had Peter merely found an environment and fellow sailors that simply inspired his patriotism? No records survive to tell the tale of why or how Peter came to volunteer for the mission.

Fort Fisher, NC, was a Confederate fort which protected the shipping lanes into Wilmington, NC, so vital for the Confederate war effort. British smugglers, known as blockade runners, would bring in important supplies for the Confederacy, including munitions, clothing, and food. Cotton and tobacco would be smuggled out to pay for these foreign goods.

The Union knew that the key to success was to choke off the flow of supplies so desperately needed by the Confederate Army. Fort Fisher’s defenses needed to be neutralized. The problem was that the Fort was well-built, and a land assault was expected to be long and costly.

The U.S.S. Louisiana was built in 1861 and was a propeller-driven iron hull steamer. The plan was to strip her, load her hull with explosives, tow the powder-laden boat under cover of darkness as close to the walls of the fort as possible, and detonate her. Naval ordnance experts were not in favor of the idea.

The U.S.S. Wilderness towed the U.S.S. Louisiana into position, about 300 yards offshore from the walls of the fort, late in the evening of December 23rd. Captain Rhind from the U.S.S. Agawam and his volunteer crew, including Peter, were aboard the Louisiana.

Once the fuses and fires were lit, the volunteer crew boarded the small skiffs attached to the U.S.S. Louisiana and rowed back to the Wilderness, anchored a safe distance away.

In his report of the mission, Captain Rhind wrote, “When all was fairly done, we observed that the vessel would not tail inshore, and therefore let go another anchor with short scope. We then took to the boat and reached the Wilderness in safety at precisely midnight, slipped her anchor, and steamed out at full speed, reaching in less than an hour a point about 12 miles distant from the powder boat, when we hove to and ran our steam down.”

“At precisely 1:40 a.m., the explosion took place, the shock being hardly felt, and four distinct reports heard. What result was occasioned near the vessel we can only estimate by the feeble fire of the forts the next day. My opinion is that owing to the want of confinement and insufficient fuzing of the mass, much of the powder was blown away before ignition and its effect lost.”

The mission was a failure. Nonetheless, the volunteer crew was hailed as heroes and was awarded the Congressional Medal of Honor.

The Medal of Honor was first awarded during the Civil War. Initially, a medal bestowed upon Navy personnel, legislation was signed into law on July 12, 1862, to include the Army troops.

Of the 3,464 Medals of Honor awarded to date, just under half, 1,522, were awarded during the Civil War. Regardless, it was a high honor to be the recipient of this prestigious award.

Peter returned home to Bethlehem and resumed his life as Peter Van Hoesen. He and Nancy would have four more children: Garrett, born in 1865, who died as an infant, Helen Jane, born in 1867; Anna, born in 1872; and Peter, born in 1873.

Nancy died on April 17, 1875, from consumption and was buried in Mt. Pleasant Cemetery in South Bethlehem. Her two-year-old daughter, Anna, had died of the disease two months earlier, on February 20, 1875. Peter was left alone to raise his surviving children, 14-year-old Hannah, 8-year-old Helen Jane, and his two-year-old son, Peter.

On June 20, 1875, Peter was enumerated in the Town of Coeymans, living alone in the household of Ambrose Halsted and working as a farm laborer.

Peter married Charlotte Isabella, the daughter of Jacob and Margaret Mansfield, on September 6, 1875, at the Coeymans Dutch Reformed Church. The couple would have no children. Hannah and Helen Jane married and established households of their own. Young Peter Van Hoesen, however, was admitted to the Albany Orphan Asylum on May 8, 1879, at the tender age of 6 and was never heard from again.

On August 4, 1886, Peter Van Hoesen applied for an invalid’s pension, which was approved. He made no secret, at the time, that his alias was James Sullivan.

Peter’s name appears as one of the founding members of A.O. Bliss Post 305, Grand Army of the Republic in New Baltimore. Peter used his real name in the application, indicating that he had served in the Navy.

In the 1890 Veteran’s Schedule, Peter appeared on the Soldiers and Seaman Schedule, stating that his disability began when he was shot in the head. He also stated that he was discharged from the Navy on April 27, 1865, after serving 1 year, 6 months, and 8 days. I have not discovered how nor when his injury occurred.

Peter lived a long life, outliving his second wife, Charlotte, who died in 1908. He moved back to the Town of Bethlehem after her death and eventually moved in with his eldest daughter, Hannah, her husband, George Snyder, and their large family.

Peter died on May 9, 1918, in his 87th year, and was laid to rest beside his second wife in the Coeyman’s Hollow Cemetery.

His tombstone noted that he had served in the 7th Connecticut Volunteer Regiment. No notation was made that he had served in the 18th Regiment NYV, nor was there any mention of his Medal of Honor.

Further to the Act of February 6, 1907, Peter Van Hoesen was awarded a pension of $20 per month, effective April 18, 1907. He was listed as an Army Invalid, having served as Private James Sullivan in the 7th Connecticut Volunteer Regiment and also as an Ordinary Seaman aboard the U.S.S. Agawan. His pension was increased to $30 effective June 11, 1912, and $40 effective June 10, 1918.

Rick Shanks noted that the long arm of the government finally made the connection that James Sullivan was the Peter Van Hoesen who had deserted from the 18th Regiment NYV and stopped his pension payments.

On August 27, 2016, a new marker was installed beside Peter’s old gravestone. It proudly indicated that he had served in both regiments and was a Medal of Honor recipient. A moving 30-minute ceremony followed the unveiling of the new gravestone. Kudos go out to Rick Shanks and the other members of the VFW Post 9595 from Ravena and the National Medal of Honor Society for their perseverance and dedication to this project.

Finally, Peter had received the due recognition he deserved.


Buried in Coeyman’s Hollow Cemetery, 32 Gedney Hill Road, Coeymans Hollow, New York. Photos by Jeff DeWitt.


END

Published by jeffd1121

USAF retiree. Veteran advocate. Committed to telling the stories of those who died while in the service of the country during wartime.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.